Forget about another share trading review
Former Fonterra director Nicola Shadbolt says the recent collapse of a few dairy cooperatives should be blamed on their strategy, not their co-op structure.
Australian farmer Brian McLaren has been a loyal Murray Goulburn supplier for 48 years but the latest price blow could be the final straw.
“Murray Goulburn has ruined me physically, financially and mentally,” says the Woolsthorpe farmer.
“I’ve had a gutsful. You can only get belted over the head so often; you can’t keep coming back.”
McLaren had hoped for an opening price about A$5.50 but more realistically expected A$5.30 with step-ups to boost it towards A$6 later in the year.
However, the season opening of A$4.70/kgMS with a forecast closing price of A$5.20 - $5.40/kg MS has him “gobsmacked”.
Now McLaren is weighing up options for transferring to another company, although he admits his choices are limited.
“I’m looking elsewhere now but my options aren’t great. We will look at Saputo or the Midfield Group or give it away.
“At $4.70 and when you factor in the 10 cents promised for loyalty it’s $4.60 I can’t make a living; nobody can.”
“I’ve been a Murray Goulburn man for well over 40 years. I’ve been supplying them since the Grassmere factory closed and they initially came to the district.”
McLaren has spoken to his accountant and says he will make a “calculated decision” on his future. “We haven’t done the sums. We don’t want to jump out of the frying pan into the fire. It has to be a commercial decision.”
McLaren, who milks 700 cows, says starting at the low price would cost him A$480,000.
“We produced 480,000kgMS last year and if we’re a dollar under our competitors that means I just lost $480,000.”
He remains frustrated about the cooperative’s problems.
“I understand they’re hamstrung in regard to what they can do, but I want to know why.
“If Saputo are trying to source millions of litres to run a cheese factory -- Murray Goulburn has one at Cobram; why can’t we sell the same product and chase an extra 10 million litres.”
McLaren (65) is now considering his future. “I’m working my arse off for nothing. I don’t mind working hard but I want to be paid for it.”
Entries opened on Monday, 5 October 2026 for the 2027 New Zealand Dairy Industry Awards (NZDIA), which organisers describe as the nation's biggest celebration of excellence in the dairy sector.
Waikato milk processor Tatua has again declared a record milk payout to farmer shareholders, leaving other processors in the dust.
A Labour-led Government won’t be bringing back the controversial freshwater rules of 2020.
National’s much-touted free trade deal with India featured in the Rural Issues Debate at Mystery Creek, Hamilton on Wednesday night.
New Zealand's 2026-27 freshwater fishing season has opened, with anglers encouraged to head to rivers and lakes over the coming days as conditions look favourable across much of the country.
Central Otago District Council (CODC) has voted against a plan to spread treated sewage sludge from Cromwell and Alexandra on farmland near Lauder, a decision Federated Farmers says reflects strong opposition from rural residents.
OPINION: It seems Canterbury processor Synlait is still in the doldrums.
OPINION: Get offside with New Zealand First leader Winston Peters at your own peril.