Monday, 09 November 2015 09:25

Will the China bashing stop? — Editorial

Written by 
Yes, China is a big investor in NZ, but it is not the biggest. Yes, China is a big investor in NZ, but it is not the biggest.

KPMG’s latest research report on foreign direct investment in New Zealand gives perspective to much of the uninformed hype over this issue, in particular the emphasis on China’s role.

The report shows that of the $26.3 billion invested in NZ in the past two years the Chinese have invested $1.3b in dairy and milk processing.

While China is still a big investor it falls well behind the US, Canada, Australia and Europe and only just heads off Singapore. In land purchases, again the US (40%) heads the list, then comes Europe (14%) then China (13%).

Yes, China is a big investor in NZ, but it is not the biggest.

Perhaps China’s liking for our high profile, and quite sensitive, dairy industry is the cause of the feathers – especially political – getting ruffled.

Have Kiwis an inherent fear of China? This will suddenly switch to the US if Donald Trump by some amazing streak of stupidity gets elected as president.

We have not reacted to British investment after seeing that country doing itself bewildering self-harm by voting for Brexit.

Look at our neighbours Australia. A wave of Chinese investment in agriculture, housing and public infrastructure assets has also caused concern. Last year Canberra reduced the threshold at which purchases by foreign investors of farmland must be cleared by regulators from A$240m to A$15m.

New Hope is one of dozens of Chinese companies that have invested in Australia’s agricultural sector over the past few years. Chinese companies now own about 1.5m hectares of farmland. While that is less than 0.5% of Australia’s agricultural land, polls show rising public angst over sales of land to Chinese companies. In response, authorities have tightened foreign investment rules and this year blocked the proposed A$370m purchase of Kidman & Co by Shanghai Pengxin Group.

The KPMG report shows overseas investors view NZ agribusiness as a good place for their cash. They are not obliged to put it here, they can easily go elsewhere.

They target the dairy industry in particular, well ahead of forestry and wine and, to a lesser extent, sheep and beef.

If NZ is to produce high value niche products, it needs capital but the pool of capital here is insufficient to advance the cause.

Kiwis should be pleased that others can see opportunities for us to refine our base products and make them the Louis Vuitton’s of the food industry.

NZ still finds it hard to get away from producing commodities, sadly still lording that aspiration – a hangover from the days of the ‘number 8 wire’ mentality. Fred Dagg had it right: “we don’t know how lucky we are mate”. Right Trev?

More like this

Birth woes

OPINION: What does the birth rate in China have to do with stock trading? Just ask a2 Milk Company.

Featured

Pāmu Opens Farm Gates for Summer Open Farm Days

State farmer Pāmu is opening its farm gates this summer in an effort to give the rural sector the opportunity to see how large-scale, multi-system farming is delivering productivity and profitability across New Zealand.

DairyNZ: Waikato Farmers Need Certainty on PC1 Rules

DairyNZ says Waikato farmers need certainty on Plan Change 1, but they say that certainty must be matched with practical, workable rules and a clear transition that doesn't get ahead of the new resource management system currently under review.

National

Machinery & Products

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

Taking On Winnie

OPINION: No one messes around with Winston Peters, more so in a general election year.

Full of Surprises

OPINION: Staying on Federated Farmers, this week's annual general meeting in Auckland is shaping up to be an interesting one.

» Connect with Dairy News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter