Tuesday, 25 September 2018 11:50

Has Fonterra delivered?

Written by  George Moss
George Moss. George Moss.

OPINION: Fonterra has delivered more real value to me than the other processors would have.

Mark Townshend's article (Dairy News August 28 issue) raises interesting questions for me, namely what is the value of Fonterra to my dairy business and has it delivered?

No doubt Fonterra has challenges and hard questions need to be, and are being, asked, but did it deliver to shareholder suppliers during the awful downturn years between  2014-15 and 2016-17 when the pressure was really on us all?

When milk is over $6/kgMS dairying is gold. It is the downtimes that ‘kill’ you. 

I have used Dairybase as a source of credible data to determine the value of Fonterra to my business. Looking over the three seasons 2014-15, 2015-16 and 2016-17, and averaging the performance of the suppliers to the two largest companies -- Fonterra and Open Country Dairy -- one can see that there is a marked difference between the financial performance of these suppliers (see the data above right, available to all people participating in Dairybase).

Note that these are average figures on suppliers over three years, as this removes distortions from either early or retrospective payments for milk supplied. There is a risk of bias, i.e. it may be higher performing dairy farmers who enter their financial data in Dairybase, so be aware that behind every average is a bell-shape performance curve.

In short, the difference of $557/ha in operating profit comes from $320/ha gain from extra milk income and another $237/ha is attributable to lower operating costs. Analysis of farm working expenses shows that Fonterra farmers were able to reduce costs by 50c/kgMS versus 32c/kgMS for OCD farmers. It would be interesting to know whether this is because of a difference in supply curves – seasonal versus flat?

I argue that a 58% difference in operating profit could be the difference between sustainability or otherwise. Over the three seasons this equates to about $1200/ha or $120,000 on a 100ha farm. 

Note that the difference in net profit/ha is likely to be larger again as there is on average $272/ha less debt servicing by the Fonterra shareholders (MS/ha x debt servicing/kg).

has fonterra deliveredFonterra shareholders would need on average another 60c/kgMS to get them to that magic profit of $2000/ha, i.e. a $5.70 milk price or better. OCD suppliers would need a $5.86 milk price or better to achieve the same profit in that same period.

The above data has real implications for Fonterra’s capital structure, which must be on the table for discussion along with the current ‘purpose and values’ debate.

If one uncouples the value-added business from milk supply, as some are suggesting, then farmers without access to income stream would have been potentially $320/ha per year worse off for those three seasons -- about $1000/ha, serious money when times are tough.

Separation could lead to a ‘two masters’ scenario in which both try to maximise milk price and dividend and subsequent share value. This is difficult and hugely risky if one wants to have a truly strong cooperative.

Fonterra’s purpose has been and always must be to deliver the maximum sustainable amount of cash through it’s shareholder gates; value will follow after that.

Has Fonterra delivered more real value to me than the other processors would have? My gut feeling is an absolute ‘yes’. In doing so it has benefitted every other dairy farmer in the country by setting a milk price benchmark.

Do we need to keep debating the issues? Yes.

• George Moss is a Tokoroa farmer and Fonterra supplier.

More like this

Cynical politics

OPINION: There is zero chance that someone who joined Fonterra as a lobbyist, then served as a general manager of Fonterra's nutrient management programme, and sat on the board of Export NZ, a division of lobbyist group Business New Zealand, doesn't understand that local butter (and milk and cheese) prices are set by the international commodity price.

Why is butter so expensive in New Zealand? Fonterra explains

Kiwis love their butter, and that's great because New Zealand produces some of the best butter in the world. But when the price of butter goes up, it's tough for some, particularly when many other grocery staples have also gone up and the heat goes on co-operative Fonterra, the country's main butter maker. Here the co-op explains why butter prices are so high right now.

Featured

DairyNZ thanks farm staff

August 6 marks Farm Worker Appreciation Day, a moment to recognise the dedication and hard mahi of dairy farm workers across Aotearoa - and DairyNZ is taking the opportunity to celebrate the skilled teams working on its two research farms.

Editorial: Getting RMA settings right

OPINION: The Government has been seeking industry feedback on its proposed amendments to a range of Resource Management Act (RMA) national direction instruments.

Why is butter so expensive in New Zealand? Fonterra explains

Kiwis love their butter, and that's great because New Zealand produces some of the best butter in the world. But when the price of butter goes up, it's tough for some, particularly when many other grocery staples have also gone up and the heat goes on co-operative Fonterra, the country's main butter maker. Here the co-op explains why butter prices are so high right now.

National

Machinery & Products

Fliegl offers effluent solutions

Founded in Germany as recently as 1977, today, the Fliegl Group employs more than 1100 workers, offering an expansive range…

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

Fatberg

OPINION: Sydney has a $12 million milk disposal problem.

Synlait snag

OPINION: Canterbury milk processor Synlait's recovery seems to have hit another snag.

» Connect with Dairy News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter