Wednesday, 25 January 2017 14:55

Battle won, war not over — Editorial

Written by 
Using misleading information to portray the whole dairy industry as guilty of polluting waterways is an old Greenpeace trick. Using misleading information to portray the whole dairy industry as guilty of polluting waterways is an old Greenpeace trick.

Some newspaper headlines refer to a victory for Greenpeace, but is it?

Using misleading information to portray the whole dairy industry as guilty of polluting waterways is an old Greenpeace trick.

It has worked with the Advertising Standards Authority this time, unfortunately. Let’s hope DairyNZ’s appeal helps undo the injustice caused by the ruling.

DairyNZ lodged a complaint with the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) late last year about a Greenpeace television advert.

The advert contained images and statements about rivers, industrial dairy farming, and irrigation, effectively saying dairying is the sole polluter of our waterways. Eleven other complaints about the advert were also received by the ASA.

DairyNZ is appealing the decision because it believes the information provided by Greenpeace in its response to the original complaint made by DairyNZ and other complainants is also misleading. Nor does it reflect any of the information DairyNZ provided to Greenpeace when they met in November, about the extensive work on dairy farms to protect the environment.

More such work is needed, but dairy farmers have made tremendous progress in fencing waterways, riparian planting, restoring wetlands and installing effluent management systems. Over the last five years farmers have spent at least $1 billion on this work – voluntarily. The countryside is where dairy farmers live and work, and they are great stewards of their environment.

Water measurement is succeeding, notably in Waikato and Manawatu, and to this long-term effort dairy farmers are fully committed.

Greenpeace has used the ASA ruling to garner media coverage. Right now it’s winning the publicity war.

Farmers must not take this lying down. As individual farmers, if you’re on social media and you have a good story to tell about the water quality on your farm, tell it.

Andrew Hoggard says Federated Farmers members have posted pictures of themselves drinking from farm waterways. “I have been amazed at the number of environmentalists, who supposedly want clean waterways, who get upset at seeing us in our clean rivers and drinking from them.”

A final decision on Greenpeace’s misleading advertisement is pending. It is basking in glory after winning this battle.

But let’s not let them win the war by spreading lies about the dairy industry.

More like this

Bridging the gap with rural New Zealand

OPINION: One thing I keep hearing from rural New Zealanders is the importance of relationships. Strong relationships don’t just happen - they take trust, consistency, and time.

Can't help itself

OPINION: Greenpeace claims that the appointment of Dr John Roche as the PM's Chief Science Advisor is handing the powers to polluters.

Featured

LIC Space folds for good

Farmer co-operative LIC has closed its satellite-backed pasture measurement platform – Space.

Editorial: Time for common sense

OPINION: The case of four Canterbury high country stations facing costly and complex consent hearing processes highlights the dilemma facing the farming sector as the country transitions into a replacement for the Resource Management Act (RMA).

National

DairyNZ Farmers Forum underway

Over 300 farmers and rural professionals have gathered in Hamilton for the first DairyNZ Farmers Forum for this year.

Machinery & Products

Shearing legend hooked on CanAm

Sir David Fagan, world-renowned competitive sheep shearer with 642 shearing titles worldwide and a knighthood to his name, now runs…

50 years of tractor pull

This year, the Fieldays Tractor Pull, in association with PTS Logistics, mark a major milestone – 50 years of crowd-thrilling…

The Wrangler's birthday bash

It's the Wrangler Limited’s 30th birthday and to celebrate the milestone a prototype of the E Series Wrangler - a…

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

Free speech

OPINION: The Free Speech Union is taking this one too far.

Drug survey

OPINION: New national data from The Drug Detection Agency (TDDA), a leading workplace drug tester, shows methamphetamine (meth) use is…

» Connect with Dairy News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter