Why Fonterra accepted defeat in the dairy aisle
OPINION: Fonterra's sale of its consumer dairy business to Lactalis is a clear sign of the co-operative’s failure to compete in the branded consumer market.
FONTERRA IS on the slippery slope towards demutualisation and a board “update” on the cause, the Trading Among Farmers proposal, yet again failed to recognise this, says one of a growing number of shareholders calling for a second vote on the proposal.
South Canterbury dairy farmer Leonie Guiney is one of several shareholders who, after seeking expert legal advice, says the current proposal will see farmer control undermined.
Fonterra’s Sky TV broadcast on Friday (December 16) “had no update in it” and while “it’s positive Fonterra has acknowledged farmers have an issue with the shareholders fund structure,” Guiney says that acknowledgement has only come as a result of grassroots shareholders exposing the threat TAF presents.
“What we’ve discovered is that the locked box is in fact an empty box. The asset was sitting on the trust balance sheet in the proposal all along, completely compromising the commitment of 100% farmer ownership and control.”
For nearly two years, Fonterra’s board and management have been saying the TAF proposal will retain 100% farmer owner and control, but with the asset corresponding to shares showing on the unit trust’s balance sheet, unit holders, ie outside investors, would have legal rights under company and trust law to expect trust managers to act in their best interests. In effect that would be to maximise dividend, and minimise milk price, explains Guiney.
“Now we have been told they [Fonterra management] have three more options, the detail of which they are working on, and one of them is leaving the current proposal as is!
“How can Sir Henry keep repeating ad nauseam the line about 100% ownership and control and leave the current proposal on the table?”
Assurances shareholders ‘will be informed in due time’ from Fonterra’s board also ring hollow, she says.
“How many times have we heard this? How much closer is this to being pushed through parliament?
“But the biggest question of all is this – at what point did our cooperative’s purpose shift from looking after the interests of its co-op members and owners to looking after the interests of future investors in the NZX , including the NZ Govt?
“How do we halt this no longer subtle move towards demutualisation of our cooperative? How do we as the producers of the milk protect future generations of milk producers against the short-term gain mentality of those who would prefer to trade?”
Guiney is also concerned at how the issue is being reported in certain media outlets, given NZX would be likely to benefit from a demutualisation of Fonterra.
“Remember, NZX now owns both NZ Dairy Exporter and Farmers Weekly.”
Suggestions in the latter, December 19, that 4% dry shares in Fonterra as of July 2011 ‘is one measure of farmers’ appetite to expose themselves to non production linked share ownership and dividend income’ also grate.
“To me 4% looks like a very poor appetite and is in reality just a reflection of the expected fluctuation in milk production due to normal climatic variation, possibly plus a little headroom on farms that anticipate expanding output...
“We have no appetite for ‘non production linked share ownership’ and see it as the biggest risk to the future of our milk price and cooperative.”
A Fonterra spokesman re-iterated to Rural News that the Board, Shareholders’ Council and Management remain totally committed to 100% farmer ownership and control, and they are in regular contact with shareholders about TAF and getting their feedback.
“This will continue into the New Year and we have advised our farmers that there will be a round of farmer meetings from Jan 31 – Feb 3.”
The Ministry for the Environment is joining as a national award sponsor in the Ballance Farm Environment Awards (BFEA from next year).
Kiwis are wasting less of their food than they were two years ago, and this has been enough to push New Zealand’s total household food waste bill lower, the 2025 Rabobank KiwiHarvest Food Waste survey has found.
OPINION: Sir Lockwood Smith has clearly and succinctly defined what academic freedom is all about, the boundaries around it and the responsibility that goes with this privilege.
DairyNZ says its plantain programme continues to deliver promising results, with new data confirming that modest levels of plantain in pastures reduce nitrogen leaching, offering farmers a practical, science-backed tool to meet environmental goals.
'Common sense' cuts to government red tape will make it easier for New Zealand to deliver safe food to more markets.
Balclutha farmer Renae Martin remembers the moment she fell in love with cows.
OPINION: Should cows in NZ be microchipped?
OPINION: Legislation being drafted to bring back the controversial trade of live animal exports by sea is getting stuck in the…