Saturday, 28 March 2015 00:00

Indian companies can help NZ clinch FTA

Written by 
Sunil Kaushal (left) Prime Minister John Key and Nandan Nilekani. Sunil Kaushal (left) Prime Minister John Key and Nandan Nilekani.

Prime Minister John Key says India knows it needs a free trade agreement (FTA) with New Zealand, though an FTA is always “challenging” for the agricultural sector of any country we negotiate with.

But the technology transfers and other benefits to India of an FTA would far outweigh any downside for Indian producers of New Zealanders selling products there, Key told an Auckland business summit.

He said the former Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh had told him privately that he “had to feed his people” and “it was not easy”.

India has over a billion people so there are massive opportunities for New Zealand companies there, Key told the India New Zealand Business Council summit in Auckland on March 13.  “Capturing a tiny fraction of that market is massive from New Zealand’s point of view. But it’s equally important for India.

“The FTA will only happen when Indian companies lobby the Indian Government because there will always be resistance.

“An FTA doesn’t complete economic transactions; it is actually just an entree to each other’s markets. It is a symbol that you are very serious about what you are doing and you want to build a long term relationship.”

The summit was attended by business leaders and entrepreneurs from India, many here for the World Cup Cricket.

Key’s comments were part of a wide range of views on the FTA, with a number of Indian representatives arguing that an FTA was not immediately necessary for good business collaboration and partnerships between the business communities of both countries. New Zealand’s technology, ideas, innovation and know-how, including dairy production, processing and supply chains, were cited as among the best “products” we could export.

Several speakers also said dealing with the individual states and sectors within India may provide more immediate opportunities for business and trade than getting a government-to-government agreement.

Rupert Holborow, MFAT economic division manager, who led the 10th round of the FTA negotiations with India, says India’s population will soon be the world’s largest and its younger demographic and growing GDP should compel New Zealand to recognise it needs to engage more with India.

He said an FTA would bring tangible benefits but was also symbolic as a statement of intent by both governments as to how they wanted to characterise the bilateral relationship as it develops.

However, just home from leading the 10th round, he said “with sadness I [see] there is still a considerable distance to close if we are to conclude our FTA. I can’t see it happening imminently. I wish I could say otherwise; it’s a tough long road ahead.”

But New Zealand hasn’t lost hope and doesn’t intend giving up. “But a key message is... I don’t believe we should hold off our engagement strategy with India waiting for something that may still take some time to materialise.”

Indian high commissioner to New Zealand Ravi Thapar said New Zealand has smart technologies which could connect well with Indian industry. “Rather than New Zealand just projecting itself as a leader in agriculture it should project itself as a leader in smart technologies,” including dairy production, agriculture and general food production.

Primary Industries Minister Nathan Guy said India has the world’s largest dairy industry and a “milk revolution” could be achieved by modernising the supply chain and improving productivity by better animal husbandry and genetics. “These are all areas New Zealand knows a lot about and creates exciting opportunities in partnerships between the two countries.” New Zealand also offered high value premium products. 

INZBC executive member Sameer Handa said for New Zealand business trying to start in India, the country is too big so they should bring it down to the states, the sectors and the markets they wanted to get into. 

“That state level understanding is crucial; that is the unit in which you can actually do business.” He says the new Prime Minister, Narendra Modi, has launched ‘cooperative federalism’ which is pushing more money and responsibility to state level. Many reforms will be at state level.

Entrepreneur Nandan Nilekani also said “don’t get stuck on Dehli. Go to the state governments because they can get a lot of stuff done now. That is the way forward. Do not be obsessed with whether things get done in Dehli or not.”

China trade great but what if...?

New Zealand risks becoming too dependent on China, says John Key.

“I am very pro our China relationship as New Zealanders would know. I have stood up for that relationship despite the politics that sometimes collect along the way.” It has made New Zealand stronger and seen us through the global financial crisis.

“But New Zealand has had experience of being too dependent on one market… when we were pretty much Britain’s farm in the South Pacific. When it joined the European Common Market in the early 1970s the impact on New Zealand was dramatic.

“The long term risk to New Zealand would be [our becoming] totally China-dependent, and then if, for whatever reason, the relationship going sour; or it might be something completely beyond our control.”

Key said we needed diversification in New Zealand companies and markets.

 

More like this

Editorial: Elusive India FTA

OPINION: Without doubt, a priority of the Government this year will be to gain traction on the elusive free trade deal with India.

Hort exporters eye Indian market

Exporters need to understand that India should not be seen as just one country to export to, rather a country of many unique states and regions.

Securing the elusive India FTA

New Zealand's support for India during its current global security crisis could be key to securing a free trade agreement with the nation, according to the head of one of the country's largest independent accounting firms.

McClay off to India - again

Almost a year to the day from when he made his first trip to India, Trade Minister Todd McClay is jetting off there again just before Christmas.

Trump tariffs

OPINION: Former politicians seem incapable of staying away from the limelight after they retire.

Featured

Let the games begin!

New Zealand's largest celebration of rural sports athletes and enthusiasts – New Zealand Rural Games - is back for its 10th edition, kicking off in Palmerston North from Thursday, March 6th to Sunday, March 9th, 2025.

The future of beef breeding

Progeny testing at Pāmu’s Kepler farm in Southland as part of Beef + Lamb New Zealand’s Informing New Zealand Beef programme is showing that the benefits of hybrid vigour could have a massive impact on the future of beef breeding.

Editorial: GMO furore

OPINION: Submissions on the Government's contentious Gene Technology Bill have closed.

Chilled cow cuts enter China

Alliance Group has secured greater access for chilled beef exports into China following approval of its Levin and Mataura plants to supply that market. With its first load of beef from Levin clearing Chinese customs in early January and a shipment from Mataura recently arriving in China, journalist Leo Argent talked to Alliance general manager safety and processing Wayne Shaw.

National

Certainty welcomed

There's been very little reaction to the government science reform announcement, with many saying the devil will be in the…

Science 'deserves more funding'

A committee which carried out the review into New Zealand's science system says the underinvestment will continue to compromise the…

Machinery & Products

Landpower win global award

Christchurch-headquartered Landpower and its Claas Harvest Centre dealerships has taken out the Global After Sales Excellence award in Germany, during…

Innovation, new products galore

It has been a year of new products and innovation at Numedic, the Rotorua-based manufacturer and exporter of farm dairy…

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

No buyers

OPINION: Australian dairy is bracing for the retirement of an iconic dairy brand.

RIP Kitkat V

OPINION: Another sign that the plant-based dairy fallacy is unravelling and that nothing beats dairy-based products.

» Connect with Dairy News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter