Tuesday, 07 July 2020 08:25

Court case dilemma

Written by  Staff Reporters
Former Federated Farmers sharemilkers section chairman Richard McIntyre. Former Federated Farmers sharemilkers section chairman Richard McIntyre.

The recent court case involving sharemilker Tony Kuriger, the son of a National MP, has created “a concerning precedent”.

So says former Federated Farmers sharemilkers section chairman Richard McIntyre.

Kuriger was convicted and fined by Palmerston North District Court for the ill-treatment of cows on a farm at Hukanui​, Wairarapa.

McIntyre says there are now questions around animal welfare obligations in a sharemilking relationship. 

“It was determined that if the condition of the cow races is causing lameness and the farm owner is not prepared to fix them, then it is up to the sharemilker to repair them and attempt to recover the cost from the farm owner. 

“If the farm owner has already refused to repair them, it is unlikely this will be an easy or fast process. 

“Given the considerable amount of money involved, there would be very few sharemilkers with the ability to cashflow such an undertaking. 

“This places an even greater obligation on the sharemilker in terms of due diligence and also considerably increases the level of risk that they take on.”

McIntyre stepped down after four years in the role. He says the Feds sharemilkers section is in safe hands with Aaron Passey as chairman.

McIntyre believes sharemilking still remains an attractive option for those who want to be their own boss in the industry. Sharemilkers can choose their own staff, own herds and make decisions around animal breeding.

However, he says the dairy industry is evolving and sharemilkers must continue to evolve.

 “There is still a lot to be done...the Zero Carbon Bill and the National Policy Statement (NPS) on Freshwater will change many farm systems and the terms of many sharemilking agreements will need to be renegotiated in order for them to remain viable. 

“This will be a challenge particularly in areas where the change required dramatically affects the farm’s profitability and therefore the farm owner’s ability to absorb the increased cost.”

Staffing issues remain a worry on farms but Covid-19 has presented the sector an opportunity to improve its talent pool.

“There will be many displaced workers who aspire to enter a new industry and work their way up.”

More like this

Dreams aren't plans

OPINION: Milking It reckons if you're National, looking at recent polls, the dream scenario is that the elusive economic recovery finally roars to life.

If voters see some growth and wages rising faster than prices, the government could say they've "fixed" things as they ride into the next election.

Back here on Earth though, the economy they inherited is a basket case, and the long-term headwinds are fierce.

Political commentator Liam Hehir says, "dreams are not plans" and if the turnaround doesn't come in time, National may have no choice but to go negative.

"Everybody wants to fight on the economy if they can. But when neither side has a compelling story, the contest shifts to other issues. That's not new. In fact, it's the stuff of politics everywhere, always."


 Read More:


Featured

A great outcome - Hurrell

Fonterra chief executive Miles Hurrell says the sale of the co-op’s consumer and associated businesses to Lactalis represents a great outcome for the co-op.

National

Machinery & Products

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

Dreams aren't plans

OPINION: Milking It reckons if you're National, looking at recent polls, the dream scenario is that the elusive economic recovery…

Fatberg

OPINION: Sydney has a $12 million milk disposal problem.

» Connect with Dairy News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter