Wednesday, 15 May 2024 11:55

Canada's flagrant dishonesty

Written by  Peter Burke
DCANZ executive director Kimberly Crewther. DCANZ executive director Kimberly Crewther.

Deeply cynical and completely illogical. That's how Kimberly Crewther, the executive director of DCANZ is describing the Canadian government's flagrant breach of international trade law in refusing to open its market to New Zealand dairy exports.

She says Canada's actions have already cost the NZ dairy industry $120 million and are putting at risk over a billion dollars in dairy trade to NZ.

"Canada is a recidivist breaker of international trade rules," she told Dairy News.

The issue is about Canada's refusal to comply with the rules of the Comprehensive and Progressive for Trans-Pacific Partnership (CPTPP), blocking dairy exporters' access to its market. Access to Canada's market was a condition of CPTPP membership and it refused to comply; then NZ won a dispute hearing, but this has also fallen on deaf ears in Canada.

This prompted Trade Minister Todd McClay last week to blast Canada, saying its actions were cynical and that NZ was seeking further legal advice to see what action could be taken to force the Canadian government to honour and comply with the rule of CPTPP.

"Canada's ongoing failure to meet its legal commitments is disappointing, but we have no intention of giving in on this. We back our exporters and we will defend hard-won free trade agreement commitments," he says.

Driving the Canadian government's position is the power of its dairy lobby, notes Crewther. She says she's had a meeting with them which was simply a "robust discussion" with no outcome.

By comparison to NZ, the Canadian dairy industry is small. There are just 1.3 million cows on nearly 10,000 farms and the average herd size is a mere 89 cows. But in Canada's case it appears the size is not in the number of cows - rather the number of vocal and politically active farmers. They have clearly got their government in the palm of their hand and it's election year there as well, so no surprises.

Crewther says the actions of Canada's protectionist policies in dairy have much wider implications for international dairy trade. She says Canada's dairy exports are subsidised, which severely disadvantages NZ.

"What they are doing is not only causing harm to us as a trading partner, but they are also short-changing their own consumers with higher than necessary dairy prices Canada," she says.

Crewther says by flouting international trade rules and the dispute process under CPTPP, there is growing concern that Canada's actions are diminishing the overall value of this important trade agreement.

This view was echoed last year when Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade (MFAT) deputy secretary trade and economic, Vangelis Vitalis, said frankly that Canada's approach to administering its dairy quotas is protectionist and undermines the market access agreed between CPTPP parties.

More like this

Minister raises tariffs dispute

Trade Minister Todd McClay has used a meeting of the CPTPP hosted by Canada to take that country to task for defiantly refusing to open up its dairy market to NZ.

From the CEO: A changing trade environment

Did you know that nearly 90% of total New Zealand wine sales occur offshore? That simple number means our wine businesses are the most export oriented of all the global wine industries. It also makes our sector especially sensitive to any changes in the trade rules that govern the access of our wines into international markets.

Featured

$10 milk price still on

Whole milk powder prices on Global Dairy Trade (GDT) remains above long run averages and a $10/kgMS milk price for the season remains on the card, says ASB senior economist Chris Tennent-Brown.

Industry leader not afraid to break the mould

North Canterbury dairy farmer and recently elected deputy chair of DairyNZ, Cameron Henderson is not afraid to break the mould when it comes to finding farming systems that work for him.

Climate change dilemma

Former Fonterra director Marise James says the future of the dairy industry depends upon the direction of travel with respect to climate change.

Banks urged to withdraw from alliance

Farmers are calling for Kiwi banks and their overseas parent companies need to follow the lead of America's six biggest banks and urgently withdraw from the Net Zero Banking Alliance.

National

Machinery & Products

A JAC for all trades

While the New Zealand ute market is dominated by three main players, “disruptors” are never too far away.

Pushing the boundaries

Can-Am is pushing the boundaries of performance with its Outlander line-up of all-terrain vehicles (ATVs) with the launch of the…

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

Follow the leaders

OPINION: Farmers are urging Kiwi banks and their overseas parent companies to follow the lead of America's six biggest banks…

Bouquet for bank

OPINION: Groundswell has given ANZ a shout-out for, so far, being the only one of the big four Aussie-owned banks…

» Connect with Dairy News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter