Wednesday, 12 February 2025 13:55

Editorial: Will big be better?

Written by  Peter Burke
The concept of a mega ag science institution sounds enticing, but the question remains, is big best? The concept of a mega ag science institution sounds enticing, but the question remains, is big best?

OPINION: The shakeup to the science sector with the proposed merger of four ag related crown research institutes (CRIs) into one conglomerate has drawn little public reaction.

Perhaps surprising given the importance of science to the future prosperity of NZ and the primary sector.

Much has been made by government that putting all the ag related CRI’s into one organisation will be in the interests of NZ, but no details about the cost of the benefits of the merger have been made public. These will apparently be ‘worked through’ as part of the transition planning.

The concept of a mega ag science institution sounds enticing, but the question remains, is big best? Will the new conglomerate deliver better science and be agile to change, or end up being another unwieldy bureaucratic conglomerate with a new logo? Size is not a guarantee of performance!

Former politician Steven Joyce noted in a newspaper article: “It’s a pity that the emphasis appears to be more on structure than delivery” and that “the merger is likely to be costly, distracting and achieve little” and has the hallmarks of rearranging the deckchairs in the science system.

Surprising to many is that the main gatekeeper of science funding, the Ministry for Business, Innovation and Employment (MBIE), wasn’t reviewed in tandem with the CRI’s. To leave them out of this review is questionable. Scientists have long complained that the biggest problem they face is dealing with MBIE’s complex ‘bureaucratic nightmare’ system to get bids for funding accepted.

There is talk of a review of MBIE and a proposal to create new science ministry. We had one of those in 1990’s and early 2000’s. So, is it back to square one again?

Finally, and most importantly, will there be more money for science in the future, and will there be better communication of science as the result of the report? Don’t hold your breath!

Peter Burke is the founder of the Science Communicators Association of NZ

More like this

Featured

Students' Strobe Light Targets Nesting Birds in Tractors

During the nesting season, from September to December, industrious starlings can quickly build nests in the darker areas behind tractor and vehicle, usually close to hot engines, typically resulting in localised damage or in some cases complete write-offs.

NZ Tractor Deliveries Up 5% Year to Date to September

With the last couple of months having seen some potential tractor purchases put on hold with the impending election and continued input cost rises, year-to-date figures, ending September, has seen deliveries up around 5% over the same period in 2025, with a total of 2026 units.

MPI's Diana Reaich on Non-Tariff Barriers and Trade Access

The head of the Ministry for Primary Industries (MPI) trade and international relations group says New Zealand is well-positioned to secure trade access and compete internationally as the world becomes more complicated, demanding and uncertain.

National

Machinery & Products

Claas Balers Turn 30

Claas built its first variable chamber round baler - the Variant 100 - in 1996, so 2026 marks 30 years…

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

'LinkedIn Greens'

OPINION: The same mainstream media muppets that brought you Jacindamania in 2017 have been flat out pimping for the Opportunities…

UK Warning

OPINION: Your old mate reckons the atrocious way farmers in the UK are treated by their lords and masters in…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter