Thursday, 19 December 2024 09:55

Pricing ag emissions 'is wrong'

Written by  Peter Burke
Red meat farmers want the Government to consider alternatives to emissions pricing. Red meat farmers want the Government to consider alternatives to emissions pricing.

 Pricing agricultural emissions is wrong and there are better ways, says chair of Beef + Lamb NZ Kate Acland.

A report commissioned by B+LNZ shows that New Zealand is out of step with global climate policies. The report produced by New Zealander Macauly Jones, an independent agricultural and sustainability consultant based in Berlin, surveyed sixteen jurisdictions internationally to see how they are dealing with reducing agricultural emissions.

Acland says only one other country besides NZ - Denmark - is considering pricing agricultural emissions and their scheme is heavily subsidised.

She says B+LNZ is not saying that it doesn't have a part to play in reducing agricultural emissions, but says she wants the Government to consider alternatives to pricing. She says there is also a myth that agriculturer is being let off the hook by excluding ruminant emissions from the ETS.

"This report is about prompting the conversation that there is a better way and that we need to reconsider how we are looking at the best way to address agricultural emissions. All pricing will achieve is a further reduction in stock numbers and that's a worry," she says.

Acland says the report shows that there are examples of other countries around the world who are addressing their agricultural emissions in a better way.

Meanwhile, the issue of agricultural emissions was in the spotlight this month with a two-day agricultural and climate change conference in Wellington. This attracted more than 400 people - a mixture of scientists, politicians, policy makers and others.

Among the keynote speakers was Agriculture Minister Todd McClay who reiterated that his government is committed to farming - noting that this was why they took agriculture out of the ETS. He says it makes no sense to have a punitive tax that says farmers must change emissions on farm.

McClay says there hasd been significant investment in finding solutions for climate change mitigation.

"Those investments are coming out of the laboratory and being tested around the world and in NZ, and over the years I think these will become available. The approach we are taking is not to tax farmers, which will see less food produced. Rather, we want to collaborate with them and find technological innovations that mean NZ gets to lead the world in food production. We are not about closing farms," he says. 

As regards setting up a pricing system for agriculture by 2030, McClay to some degree played this down, saying any consideration of a price would be done later on after many other things are done, and the bottom line was they would not send jobs and production overseas.

More like this

Celebrations at Muller Station

More than 260 people gathered at Muller Station in Marlborough recently to celebrate the 2024 Westpac + OsGro Marlborough Farmer of the Year winner.

New CEO for meat board

Nick Beeby has been appointed as the new chief executive of the New Zealand Meat Board (NZMB).

Featured

Top Maori farms named

Maori farms from Northland and Northern Hawkes Bay are the finalists in this year’s prestigious Ahuwhenua Trophy competition  for the top Maori sheep and beef farm.

Keeping it in the family

The supreme dairy exhibit at the New Zealand Dairy Event (NZDE) has a close family link to a cow who has won the same title three times.

Editorial: Climate dilemma

OPINION: The farming sector, or at least some parts of it, are preparing for a battle with the Government over its latest international climate change target.

National

FE survey underway

Beef + Lamb NZ wants farmers to complete a survey that will shed light on the financial toll of facial…

Top dairy CEO quits

Arguably one of the country's top dairy company's chief executives, Richard Wyeth has abruptly quit Chinese owned Westland Milk Products…

Machinery & Products

New home for JCB Agriculture

Power Farming has announced a new chapter in its partnership with JCB, which having represented the UK-based company’s construction equipment…

CAT's 100th anniversary

While instantly recognised as the major player in construction equipment, Caterpillar Inc, more commonly known as CAT, has its roots…

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Ruth reckons

OPINION: Ruth Richardson, architect of the 1991 ‘Mother of all Budgets’ and the economic reforms dubbed ‘Ruthanasia’, added her two…

Veg, no meat?

OPINION: Why do vegans and others opposed to eating meat try to convince others that a plant based diet is…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter