Wednesday, 23 October 2019 07:55

Farmer confidence sunk by policy uncertainty - report

Written by  Peter Burke
ANZ rural economist Susan Kilsby. ANZ rural economist Susan Kilsby.

Meat and dairy prices are strong and horticulture is leaping ahead, yet farmer and business confidence in the primary sector remains low – especially dairy.

That’s the picture painted in the latest ANZ Bank Agri Focus report. 

Its key message is that somehow NZ has been able to get good prices for its products despite the global economic slowdown.

The bank’s agricultural economist Susan Kilsby says prices on the international market are still strong. Meat returns are largely underpinned by China demand to fill the gap created by its shortage of pork. 

Better prices and the low NZ dollar are boosting returns to farmers, she says.

“Lamb and mutton prices are at record levels at the moment and beef prices aren’t too far behind,” Kilsby told Rural News

“But not a lot of stock is going through the processors at this time of the year. The lower dollar is due to the weakness of the global economy. But the good news for NZ is that its products seem unaffected by this and are fetching good prices.” 

China is the key to this, strongly demanding beef, mutton and lamb. 

Kilsby says the beef going to China is reducing the quantity going to the US, which has traditionally taken meat for the hamburger trade. These two strong markets are contributing to prices holding up well.

“There is strong demand in China for mutton and poorer lamb cuts. This has pushed up the price for culled ewes here and is underpinning lamb prices.” 

Kilsby doesn’t see the demand from China disappearing anytime soon and predicts ongoing demand for our beef.

ANZ also has a positive outlook on the dairy sector and so has revised its forecast milk payout up by 15 cents to $7.15/kgMS.

But despite this, confidence in the dairy sector is the lowest it’s been for 20 years or more, she says. The cause is the uncertainty dairy farmers are facing over environmental regulations. 

“Despite the national policy statement by the Government there is still uncertainty on how the actual rules will impact individual farmers at the regional council level,” she explained. “The industry is well aware there is change ahead, but is still working through what this will mean for farmers and their business.” 

Kilsby concedes that high debt levels in the dairy industry are also an issue. She says some banks are now requiring farmers to repay some principal on their loans, in contrast to interest only payments for some time.

Meanwhile the strong growth horticulture has seen in recent years is expected to continue -- in exports of apples, SunGold kiwifruit (sales up on last season) and growing international appetite for avocados.

“Consumers worldwide seem to love avocados, but the challenge for our industry is to supply the demand,” Kilsby said

More like this


OPINION: Your old mate can’t believe the gall of the NZ big banks crying about their ‘reduced’ profitability this year.

Commodity outlook positive

A sudden drop in log prices which impacted the New Zealand commodity price index in July seems to have stabilised, says ANZ agriculture economist Susan Kilsby.


In for the long haul

The coronavirus epidemic is going to have a bigger impact than people think it is, according to Massey University Professor of Agribusiness, Hamish Gow.

Coronavirus situation ‘dynamic’ – SFF

Silver Fern Farms is giving weekly reports to its suppliers to keep them abreast of what it describes as a ‘dynamic situation in China and one that could change very quickly’.


Southern treasure or trash?

A man who bought an opencast Southland lignite mine 18 years ago no longer sells the coal for fuel, but sings its praises as stock food, fertiliser and soil conditioner. 

» The RNG Weather Report

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound


Your old mate was disappointed, but not surprised to see a ‘study’ out of Otago University – quoted all over…

A dilemma

Your canine crusader reckons the fiercely anti GE, but pro sustainability Green Party has a dilemma on its hands, following…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter