Wednesday, 22 March 2023 13:55

Editorial: Live export ban needs a u-turn

Written by  Staff Reporters
Will Prime Minister Chris Hipkins drop the live export ban onto the policy bonfire? Will Prime Minister Chris Hipkins drop the live export ban onto the policy bonfire?

OPINION: It's the season of Government u-turns on key policies and farmers are hoping it will extend to the ban on live cattle exports.

They will be happy should Prime Minister Chris Hipkins kick the live export ban into touch, like he has done with a merger of public media entities, a social insurance scheme, hate speech reforms, a biofuels mandate and a cash-for-clunkers rebate to get Kiwis driving electric vehicles.

Hipkins says he is doing all this in the name of helping the country recover from a cost of living crisis.

This is where ACT MP Mark Cameron’s Bill makes much sense. The Ruawai farmer points out that latest forecasts show that live animal exports are expected to generate $500 million for the New Zealand economy this year.

He rightly questions whether New Zealand is wealthy enough to just flush away a half a billion dollar industry – especially amid a cost of living crisis and a natural disaster recovery.

When the Government announced the ban on livestock exports by sea in 2021, it granted the sector a two-year transition period, allowing exports to continue under tightened rules which were introduced after the sinking of the Gulf Livestock 1.

Nearly 6000 cattle and 43 crew, including two New Zealanders, were on board the Gulf Livestock 1 when it capsized in the East China Sea in 2020.

Back then, Agriculture Minister Damien O’Connor said the trade posed an unacceptable risk to New Zealand’s reputation in a world where animal welfare was under increasing scrutiny.

But the Government was advised not to proceed with the ban because it would hammer rural New Zealand.

Cameron refers to the regulatory impact statement that stated “live animal exports provide a boost to New Zealand’s economy, rural communities... any move to prohibit the export of livestock would cause an economic loss to these groups and make recovery from Covid-19 more difficult”.

Federated Farmers says New Zealand has an international reputation for strong animal welfare. It warns the global live cattle trade will continue but from countries and by exporters with lower animal standards filling the gap.

If we were still involved, our high standards would push others into lifting their game.

Cameron will hope that his Bill is picked in the ballot and tabled before MPs.

But he also suggests that if the Labour Government doesn’t want to wave goodbye to a crucial source of revenue for a recovering rural sector, they should not wait for his Bill and just repeal it immediately.

More like this

A steep learning curve

A steep learning curve, a very busy year and thank heavens for tractor therapy. That's how Associate Agriculture Minister Andrew Hoggard described his first year in Parliament to reporter Peter Burke at his dairy farm in the Manawatu during the holiday break.

Follow the leaders

OPINION: Farmers are urging Kiwi banks and their overseas parent companies to follow the lead of America's six biggest banks and urgently withdraw from the Net Zero Banking Alliance.

Banks urged to withdraw from alliance

Farmers are calling for Kiwi banks and their overseas parent companies need to follow the lead of America's six biggest banks and urgently withdraw from the Net Zero Banking Alliance.

Featured

Corn makes Christmas hit

Gisborne's record hot dry summer weather has produced rewards for one of the country's largest commercial growers based in the region - Leaderbrand.

Apricot brand makes a summer splash

Apricots from New Zealand’s largest Summer series exporter, Ardgour Valley Orchards, burst onto the world stage and domestic supermarket shelves under the Temptation Valley brand last month.

Editorial: Will big be better?

OPINION: The shakeup to the science sector with the proposed merger of four ag related crown research institutes (CRIs) into one conglomerate has drawn little public reaction.

Co-op boosts chilled exports to China

Alliance Group has secured greater access for chilled beef exports to China, following approval for two of its processing plants to supply the market.

Expo set to deliver in spades

The countdown is on to be one of the most anticipated events in the sheep and beef industry, the East Coast Farming Expo.

National

Synlait sweetens milk supply deal

Canterbury milk processor Synlait is confident of retaining its farmer supplier base following a turnaround in its financial performance.

Optimism in the air

Ag First chief executive James Allen says dairy farmer optimism is on the rise.

Machinery & Products

New distributor for Aussie equipment

Australian agricultural equipment distributor, Waringa Distribution, has increased its support to South Island farmers and contractors with the appointment of…

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

Bovaer's fate

OPINION: The fate of methane inhibitor Bovaer in NZ farming is still up in the air.

» Connect with Dairy News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter