Thursday, 07 May 2020 09:54

Co-op dilemma — Editorial

Written by  Staff Reporters
Fonterra farmers, from left, Jim Cotman, Trevor Simpson and Malcolm Lumsden want the Shareholders Council scrapped. Fonterra farmers, from left, Jim Cotman, Trevor Simpson and Malcolm Lumsden want the Shareholders Council scrapped.

OPINION: Tension's been simmering among Fonterra shareholders for some time.

Read: A group of Fonterra farmers want the Shareholders Council scrapped.

Some are unhappy with the co-op’s financial performance over the past two years, others are frustrated with the lack of information coming from the board of directors.

A group of shareholders are also venting their anger at the Fonterra Shareholders Council, a 25-member elected body tasked with the role of “representing the views of all shareholders as suppliers, owners and investors”.

It also meets regularly with Fonterra’s board and management to discuss the co-op’s performance.

Two years ago Fonterra shareholders were stunned to learn that their co-op had recorded its first ever net loss after tax of $196 million for the 2017-18 year.

What didn’t help either was confirmation that former chief executive Theo Spierings left with a final year’s salary of $8 million the same year.

Then things got worse. The following financial year, Fonterra posted a net loss of $605 million on the back of asset writedowns worth $826m, mainly on its offshore businesses.

Shareholders like Trevor Simpson, Jim Cotman, Mark Lumsden and Mike Peters of Waikato have had enough.

For them there must be a better and more efficient way for shareholders to keep a tab on their co-op’s performance.

The nasty surprises delivered by the board and management in 2018 and 2019 financial year must end.

Simpson and his group want the council to step up. That’s why the review of the council is crucial for the co-op and its 10,000 shareholders.

They want the council scrapped. Others may not be keen to go that far. But what’s certain is that things must change.

Right now the council has no say in how the co-op is run and the investments it makes both here and overseas.

The council reviews the performance of Fonterra’s investments years after millions of dollars have been poured into dud projects, like China Farms and Beingmate.

Therefore, it’s unfair to blame the council for Fonterra’s investment failures: accountability rests with the board and management.

But Fonterra directors’ hands are tired when it comes to talking directly to shareholders. NZX disclosure requirements means the co-op must deal carefully with market-sensitive information. This is the dilemma facing Fonterra. Trading Among Farmers (TAF) has broken the open and free-flowing communication link between shareholders and directors.

How can this link be restored? Will scrapping the council be enough?

These are the questions shareholders will ponder as they mull the future make-up of the council in the coming months.

More like this

Fonterra's in good shape

Fonterra released its interim results last month, showing a continuation of the strong earnings performance delivered by the co-op through the 2023 financial year. Here’s what Fonterra chair Peter McBride and chief executive Miles Hurrell said about the results…

China trade

OPINION: Last week's revelation that data relating to New Zealand MPs was stolen amid Chinese state-sponsored cyber espionage targeting two arms of the country’s Parliament could test the long-standing trade relations between the two countries.

Featured

Demand for food support increases

New findings from not-for-profit food supply and distribution organization, the New Zealand Food Network (NZFN) have revealed a 42% increase in demand for food support in 2023 compared to 2022.

Herd production performance soars

New data released by LIC and DairyNZ shows New Zealand dairy farmers have achieved the highest six week in-calf rate and lowest notin- calf rate on record.

Council lifeline for A&P Show

Christchurch City Council and the Canterbury Agricultural and Pastoral Association (CAPA) have signed an agreement which will open more of Canterbury Agricultural Park for public use while helping to provide long-term certainty for the A&P Show.

Rural Advocacy Hub announced for Fieldays

This year’s Fieldays will feature a Rural Advocacy Hub - bringing together various rural organisations who are advocating for farmers and championing their interests as one team, under one roof, for the first time.

Struggling? Give us a call

ASB head of rural banking Aidan Gent is encouraging farmers to speak to their banks when they are struggling.

National

Machinery & Products

New name, new ideas

KGM New Zealand, is part of the London headquartered Inchcape Group, who increased its NZ presence in August 2023 with…

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

Plant-based bubble bursts

OPINION: Talking about plant-based food: “Chicken-free chicken” start-up Sunfed has had its valuation slashed to zero by major investor Blackbird…

» Connect with Dairy News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter