Wednesday, 10 June 2020 09:44

Farmers win more time to appeal WRC plan changes

Written by  Sudesh Kissun
PC1 applies to about 10,000 properties covering 1.1 million hectares within the Waikato and Waipā river catchments. PC1 applies to about 10,000 properties covering 1.1 million hectares within the Waikato and Waipā river catchments.

Farmers and growers have won more time to appeal one of the country’s largest environmental plan changes.

The Environment Court has ruled that individual farmers and growers now have 70 days from May 11 to appeal Waikato Regional Council (WRC) Plan Change 1 (PC1).

All other stakeholders including milk processors and industry-good organisations have 50 days from April 28, when Level 4 lockdown ended, to file appeals.

Developed with iwi and key stakeholders, PC1 applies to about 10,000 properties covering 1.1 million hectares within the Waikato and Waipā river catchments. PC1 seeks to reduce the amount of contaminants entering the Waikato and Waipā catchments.

Both WRC and Federated Farmers had filed applications to the Environment Court seeking waivers to the timeframe to file an appeal against PC1 in the face of COVID-19 disruptions.

The council was seeking a timeframe of either 50 working days from the notice of the council’s decision on submissions or 30 working days after Alert Level 4 restrictions ended, whichever is the later date.

Justice Melanie Harland granted the council a waiver, allowing 50 working days from 28 April for appeals.

In its application Federated Farmers argued that the council’s timeframe would create “significant prejudice” to farmers and growers and sought an 80-day time for filing of appeals.

The council opposed Federated Farmers’ application on the grounds that it would “create precedent” and that there was “a high degree of uncertainty about the way it was framed, both in relation to who it covers and when it starts”.

In her ruling, Justice Harland rejected the council’s argument.

“With respect, I disagree. In relation to ‘individual farmers and grower’, it should easily be able to be identified from the submissions filed and from those submitters who appeared either themselves or through a representative farmers or growers association, who these individuals are,” Justice Harland said.

“A common-sense approach should be taken to this issue, and if it is, in my view there should be no difficulty or uncertainty identifying this group of people. However, to also provide greater clarity I determine that individual farmers and growers include individual persons and companies engaged in farming and growing enterprises.”

She also rejected the notion of any precedent effect arising from her decision.

She noted that the applications had been made in “unusual and unprecedented times”.

“There have been other applications granted during this period to extend appeal timeframes, and some in relation to plan changes.

“Each has been determined on their own facts.  This case is by far the most unusual in terms of its scale, the length of the decision under appeal, and generally the scale of the litigation that is likely to arise from the subject matter of the decision.”

Justice Harland says the 70-day timeframe for farmers and growers to file appeals will provide certainty.

“If the COVID-19 situation means a reversion is necessary, a further application can be filed to look at the situation then.”

More like this

Farmers up their game

A Waikato environmentalist who led a public campaign against poor winter grazing practices on Southland farms says farmers are making improvements.



Limited feed puts ewes at risk

Severe feed shortages in parts of the country mean many ewes are on a nutritional knife-edge heading into lambing and could be at risk of developing metabolic disorders.

Jack’s unique solution

Jason Jack was left with severe spinal injuries after a wakeboarding accident when he was 29, but that hasn’t stopped him getting out and about in difficult environments.


$10 payout!

A small but select group of Fonterra farmers are on the cusp of setting a new milk payout record.

The migrant workers dilemma

Dairy farmers want more Kiwi workers, but they also want relaxed immigration restrictions. So, what's the problem?

Producing milk, the Miraka way

The goal of Māori-owned dairy company Miraka, near Taupo, is to become the most sustainable dairy company in the world.

Machinery & Products

Landpower invests in cow central

One of Australasia’s largest, privately-owned farm machinery distributors, Landpower is building a new $10 million complex adjacent to Hamilton Airport.

Maize moisture in a moment

With forage maize playing such an important part of the New Zealand fodder supply chain, a useful hand-held moisture measuring…

» The RNG Weather Report

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

A ticking timebomb?

There could be another dairy health scare brewing in China and this one starts in our backyard.

Please explain

Does anyone in the Government understand the essential role St John Ambulance has in our society?

» Connect with Dairy News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter