Tuesday, 12 July 2022 06:55

A 'lousy' deal!

Written by  Peter Burke
Malcolm Bailey, DCANZ, says it's a lousy deal, a significantly missed opportunity and sets an awful precedent for any future trade negotiations. Malcolm Bailey, DCANZ, says it's a lousy deal, a significantly missed opportunity and sets an awful precedent for any future trade negotiations.

The chair of the organisation which represents all the New Zealand dairy companies has hit out at government politicians for failing to deliver a quality FTA with the EU for the dairy sector.

Malcolm Bailey, Dairy Companies Association of NZ (DCANZ), says the parameters the politicians finally set for the negotiations made it virtually impossible for our highly skilled trade negotiators to pull off a good deal for what he calls one of the big engine rooms of the NZ economy - the dairy industry.

"This is a lousy deal, a significantly missed opportunity and sets an awful precedent for any future trade negotiations," he says.

Bailey, who was in Brussels when the final touches were being put on the deal, says he had a sleepless night when he heard that the message from the Government to the negotiators was 'anything better than the status quo'.

He says DCANZ had urged them to keep on negotiating to get a better deal for dairy and says they were surprised at the approach they took.

He says the change in the language and the fact that NZ had signalled that it wanted a deal by June 30 was something of a cue to the EU negotiators, who knowing NZ's bottom line, appeared to adopt a tactic of stalling the negotiations and counting down the clock to the end of June.

"This appears to have made it extremely difficult for our negotiators to deliver something meaningful for the dairy and beef sectors.

"We don't use this phrase 'walk away' for us it is just continue the negotiation rather than settle a deal at this time if it wasn't going to be good enough and, as we have seen, it is not good enough for dairy. In the end it was a decisions made by the Government and I have already said how disappointed we are," he says.

Bailey says he's not at all critical of the MFAT trade negotiators, describing them as "top shelf people".

He says while DCANZ was not at the actual negotiating table, they worked alongside the MFAT people and provided analysis and information to assist them where necessary.

Minimal Result

Malcolm Bailey says, right from the start of the negotiations four years ago, it was clear that NZ was not going to get everything it wanted.

He says it then came down to what was really needed, which was tariff elimination - something we got in the UK FTA. He says, when this didn't look possible, the language used was 'achieving commercially meaningful outcomes' for the dairy and beef sectors.

"So what's the definition of that? Well, there is threshold of 5% open access to their market and 5% of 450 million people is reasonably significant, so that's the default if you like. But we have ended up miles below that," he says.

Bailey points to the fact that NZ gave up using the name Feta and says if you look at the gain the FTA for dairy, the result is minimal and not what we needed.

He says he also challenges claims by the Government on the financial benefits for dairy in the FTA as it stands. He says he strongly disagrees with financial gains the Government claims the industry will get as a result of this FTA. He says DCANZ has a completely different take on these.

What has surprised Bailey is a belief that the EU actually wanted to deal with NZ. He says issues such as NZ's support for Europe over the Ukraine war was a positive.

"The other thing was it was almost embarrassing for the EU not having a FTA with NZ when we are down to the last six in the world, sitting in a group that includes North Korea.

"So there was definitely a willingness and, as we have already noted, some sectors such as kiwifruit and horticultural crops have done well and I am pleased for them," he says. 

More like this

Changing global trade ties

OPINION: I recently returned from a market visit overseas, including the United Kingdom and Europe. These are critical, historically important and increasingly high value markets for our red meat exports.

Featured

Nichol is new PGW chair

A day after the ouster of PGG Wrightson’s chair and his deputy, the listed rural trader’s board has appointed John Nichol as the new independent chair.

Fieldays to rebuild Mystery Creek services building

The iconic services building at National Fieldays' Mystery Creek site will be demolished to make way for a "contemporary replacement that better serves the needs of both the community and event organisers," says board chair Jenni Vernon.

National

Machinery & Products

New McHale terra drive axle option

Well-known for its Fusion baler wrapper combination, Irish manufacturer McHale has launched an interesting option at the recent Irish Ploughing…

Amazone unveils flagship spreader

With the price of fertiliser still significantly higher than 2024, there is an increased onus on ensuring its spread accurately at…

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

Fonterra vote

OPINION: Voting is underway for Fonterra’s divestment proposal, with shareholders deciding whether or not sell its consumer brands business.

Follow the police beat

OPINION: Politicians and Wellington bureaucrats should take a leaf out of the book of Canterbury District Police Commander Superintendent Tony Hill.

» Connect with Dairy News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter