Thursday, 16 February 2012 10:45

Science funding impacts impartiality

Written by 

In the rural sector, many advisors and representatives are rewarded for the custom they bring in and the services/product they sell. Who then is the impartial advisor?

In New Zealand the answer is, it is difficult to tell. The Crown Research Institute is involved with land-based production research and gains less than half their income from the government. In an effort to stay afloat, they have taken on more and more commercially funded projects. So have the universities for a similar reason.

In an attempt to justify existence, research bodies have moved into activities designed to show stakeholders they are working with them. Money has been spent on surveys, field days and conferences at the expense of actual research where results can be translated to the farm and improve the bottom line – maximising the difference between production costs and value of output.

Early press releases about products which 'could' or 'might' make a difference means agricultural research is becoming like medical research – everything could be a cure for cancer... or cause it... depending how much you ingest and which week it is. Frequently the expense of the next stage means the research is left at 'could' and 'might' and sometimes classed as 'fringe' or 'alternative'.

Sufficient funding should be made available to ensure proof of concept is followed by proof of efficacy. It should not be left to the individual to bear the expense of the testing.

Farmers are coping with an economic, climatic and ecological environment which is increasingly unpredictable, within increasing restrictions on tools that can be used to reduce risk. New Zealand needs a group of top farmers and top scientists sorting out research direction – a combination of common sense and practical understanding identifying where feasible adjustments could be made within the boundaries of commercial reality for most farms. Then the government should fund it. Simple.

• Jacqueline Rowarth is Professor of Pastoral Agriculture, Massey University

Featured

New methane targets here to stay?

A drop in methane targets announced by the Government this month has pleased farmers but there are concerns that without cross-party support, the targets would change once a Labour-led Government is voted into office.

National

Machinery & Products

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Peasants' revolt

OPINION: Media luvvies at Stuff, the Spinoff and the Granny Herald are spending more time than ever navel-gazing about why…

Why so slow?

OPINION: Why does it take Treasury so long to turn around its figures on how the economy is tracking?

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter