Thursday, 19 November 2015 14:57

Paying the price for our hot air

Written by  Jacqueline Rowarth
Jacqueline Rowarth. Jacqueline Rowarth.

New Zealand is liable internationally for agricultural emissions, but the Government (taxpayers as a whole) pays for them, despite agriculture contributing nearly half the country's greenhouse gases.

A review of the ETS scheduled to begin by the end of the year could result in a change of policy.

The fundamental argument for inclusion is based on the misunderstanding of who contributes to the ETS and why, illustrated by statements from Greenpeace: "We don't see why there should be any objection to farmers doing their bit and contributing like other sectors, and like the taxpayers and like energy consumers."

Farmers are doing their bit and are contributing through taxes and energy consumption, just like other NZers.

It is the animals that aren't – they are just doing what comes naturally and the expertise of NZ farmers means that milk and meat products from NZ are associated with rather fewer GHG emissions than many countries can achieve.

But agriculture does contribute almost half the emissions from NZ.

Environment Aotearoa 2015, released by the Ministry for the Environment and StatisticsNZ last month, identified GHG as an area of concern because of increases. NZ still contributes only about 0.1% of emissions globally, but they increased 42% between 1990 and 2013. During that time agriculture increased by 14% to its current contribution of 48% of the total, while the energy sector increased 32% (more than double agriculture's increase) – now contributing 39% of the total.

Most countries have decreased their emissions by cleaning up industry, moving to renewable power and improving public transport. For NZ there are no simple options.

The OECD Economic Survey: New Zealand 2015, states that 'NZ faces difficult climate change challenges because of the high share of its greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions coming from agriculture, where there are few cost-effective abatement possibilities and because three quarters of electricity already comes from renewable sources, meaning there are fewer potential gains in generation'. The OECD also notes that transport emission intensities are high, reflecting low use of public transport and poor average vehicle fuel economy.

The OECD's solution is to reduce vehicle GHG emissions (responsible for 19% of the total), by moving towards a plug-in hybrid/electric vehicle fleet and it recommends that the Government develops a cost-effective public network of charging points to encourage their use.

Barry Crump will be turning in his grave....

For agriculture the report suggests developing a strategy to cut agricultural GHG emissions efficiently through a combination of pricing, regulation and R&D. The R&D is underway, and vaccines have been identified that could halve methane emissions. Their use is, however, several years away.

Speaking at the East Coast Hill Country Symposium held in Hastings, at the end of October, Ecologic's executive director Guy Salmon went as far as to propose removing ruminant animals from NZ! This caused consternation to Minister of Economic Development Hon Steven Joyce, because ruminants account for a huge portion of the export economy.

The answer could be to tax products at point of consumption in home or restaurant.

Professor Ralph Sims, Massey University's expert in renewable energy and a member of the IPCC Global Energy Assessment Group, points out that people have choices about what they eat and where it comes from. Taxing for GHG at point of consumption might affect their choices to NZ's advantage through premium prices.

The same can be said about transport decisions: an improved network of charging stations could encourage the switch from fossil fuel cars (with apologies to Crumpy).

Animals, however, don't have choices. They just do what comes naturally. Taxing them won't change their behaviour and reducing their numbers will affect the economy.

The Government wouldn't then have the money to invest in the public network of charging points for our new cars... Barry Crump would have something to say about that logic, as well.

• Jacqueline Rowarth is professor of agribusiness, The University of Waikato.

More like this

Dark ages

OPINION: Before we all let The Green Party have at it with their 'bold' emissions reduction plan, the Hound thought it wise to run the numbers through the old Casio.

Govt limits forestry conversions

Farmers have welcomed the Government’s move designed to limit farm to forestry conversions entering the Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS).

Faulty models used to measure emissions

OPINION: If you have kept your finger on the emissions pulse, none of the below information will be a surprise to you. However, if you are a farmer that has not been following New Zealand’s ruminant methane issue then you may be in for a nasty shock.

ETS logic - stranger than fiction

OPINION: Over the last two weeks we have seen a Bill pass through the house that removes the ETS backstop from agriculture emissions, and once again we heard some strange logic being presented.

Featured

Low interest sustainability lending from Halter, banks

Dairy and beef farmers could be eligible for lower interest lending options for financing Halter on their farms, with ANZ, ASB and BNZ now offering a pathway to sustainability loans for New Zealand’s largest virtual fencing provider.

National

Machinery & Products

Loosening soil without fuss

Distributed in New Zealand by Carrfields, Grange Farm Machinery is based in the Holderness region of East Yorkshire – an…

JCB unveils new models

The first of the UK’s agricultural trade shows was recently held at the NEC Centre in Birmingham.

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Times have changed

OPINION: Back in the 1960s and '70s, and even into the '80s, successive National government Agriculture Ministers and Trade Ministers…

Hallelujah moment

OPINION: The new Public Service Commissioner Sir Brian Roche has just had the hallelujah moment of the 21st century in…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter