Wednesday, 08 October 2025 09:55

Editorial: A new era for two co-ops

Written by Staff Reporters

font size decrease font size increase font size
Print
Email

For Fonterra farmers, the equation is simple – vote yes to divest the co-op’s consumer and related businesses and get a capital return of $2/share – a whopping $3.2 billion.

OPINION: Farmer shareholders of two of New Zealand's largest co-operatives have an important decision to make this month and what they decide could change the landscape of the dairy and meat sectors in New Zealand.

For Fonterra farmers, the equation is simple - vote yes to divest the co-op's consumer and related businesses and get a capital return of $2/share - a whopping $3.2 billion.

The vote, to take place at an online special general meeting on October 20, needs 50.1% support to pass. By all accounts, a yes vote is a shoe-in.

However, for meat co-op Alliance things are not as straightforward.

A $250m investment by Irish company Dawn Meats requires 75% support from voting farmer shareholders. With an alternative proposal doing the rounds, where shareholders will be asked to inject capital into the ailing meat processor to maintain its co-op status, a 75% yes vote for the Dawn Meats proposal could be too big a hill to climb.

Alliance bosses are delivering a stark warning to shareholders in meetings: vote yes to the Dawn Meats proposal or the company risks insolvency due to its level of debt.

They have also tabled before shareholders an independent advisory report by Northington Partners that assessed the midpoint of Dawn Meats' investment at $1.18/share - a 93% uplift on the midpoint share value for current Alliance versus Alliance post-investment.

Alliance must pay off a $188 million debt to its bankers by mid-December, a deadline that has already been extended from the end of September.

A no vote at the October 20th special general meeting would send management back to the banks to negotiate a new deal.

However, if the banks don't agree, Alliance won't have any working capital facilities next year. That could even signal the beginning of the end for a proud farmer-owned co-operative formed in 1980. Let's hope it doesn't come to that.

Over the next few weeks, shareholders of both co-ops - Fonterra and Alliance - will be thinking long and hard before casting their votes.

Whatever they decide will herald a new era for their respective co-operatives.

More like this

Alliance Group faces crucial vote on Dawn Meats deal

The future of the Alliance Group is “pretty dark” if the proposed Dawn Meats deal does not go through, says board chair Mark Wynne.

Should co-op sell its consumer brands?

OPINION: As CEO of the Dairy Board in the 1980s I was fortunate to work with a team of experienced and capable executives who made most of the brand investments that created the international consumer business Fonterra inherited. Soprole in Chile was the largest, but there were more than 20 countries where consumer marketing companies were established and Anchor and other brands were successfully launched.

Fonterra delivers $12.35 organic milk price

Fonterra has delivered a fifth straight year of record organic milk price for farmer suppliers.

Fonterra lifts milk forecast, reaffirms $10 payout

Fonterra says favourable weather conditions supporting pasture growth is boosting milk production.

Fonterra bosses’ mission to sell the $4.2b divestment plan

Fonterra chair Peter McBride, fellow directors and the management team, will front up farmer shareholders next week to explain the metrics around the proposed $4.22 billion divestment plan.

Featured

Editorial: A new era for two co-ops

South Taranaki rural health hub boosts workforce

As the first of a new series of interprofessional rural training hubs opened in South Taranaki late September, Rural Health Network has celebrated the move as a "key pathway to encourage the growth and retention of health professionals in rural areas".

Owen Jennings to represent NZ at Global Livestock Forum

Farming leader and former MP Owen Jennings will represent New Zealand at the II Congreso Mundial de Ganadería Sostenible (II World Congress on Sustainable Livestock) in Spain next month.

NZ meat industry loses $1.5b annually to non-tariff barriers

Wouldn't it be great if the meat industry could get its hands on the $1.5 billion dollars it's missing out on because of non-tariff trade barriers (NTBs)?