Groundswell ramps up ‘Quit Paris’ campaign across New Zealand
Groundswell is ramping up its 'Quit Paris' campaign with signs going up all over the country.
OPINION: Why do our rural industry group leaders (Beef+Lamb & DairyNZ), continue to mislead farmers over sequestration credits?
The simple answer is that the promise of sequestration credits was a key marketing ploy to deceive farmers into supporting the emissions pricing proposal developed by the industry group partnership, He Waka Eke Noa (HWEN).
When our industry groups offered to help the Government come up with a better emissions tax option than the Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS), they developed a dual strategy to garner farmer support.
The first part of the strategy was to continually reinforce how bad the alternative (ETS) was, through a campaign of fear. ‘You wouldn’t want to be in the ETS’ was repeated ad nauseam in print and radio media.
The second part of the strategy was to exaggerate the merits of their own proposal, downplay or completely ignore the downsides, and throw in a sweetener in the form of sequestration credits, which could be used to offset the emissions tax bill.
However, this is where honesty went out the window as our industry groups became desperate to obtain farmer support, and the HWEN consultation process turned into a slick marketing campaign, rather than genuine consultation.
Farmers should get full sequestration credits was the sales pitch – riparian planting, native bush, shelter belts, woodlots. But we weren’t told of the fine print that meant most vegetation on farms would not be eligible for credits.
In my private capacity, I have undertaken hundreds of riparian plantings for farmers over the past 20 years. Few, if any, will be eligible for credits. Similarly with native bush on farms – most of this is pre 1990 of which some may be eligible for minor ‘additionality’ credits resulting from ‘active ecological management'.
Another catch is it must be stock excluded, which means most of the native vegetation on farms pre 1990 is ineligible.
There are many exotic plantings on farms in the form of shelterbelts, trees, and small blocks. Most of these are pre- 1990, therefore also not eligible for credits. Only small, exotic plantings that don’t meet the ETS criteria (less than 1 hectare, 30 metres wide and 30% canopy cover) and post 1990 may be eligible for credits. However, the Government has thus far rightly rejected these for being too small and administratively cost ineffective.
Our industry leaders were outraged about the Government’s position on sequestration. But the truth is that it was our industry groups that designed and agreed to the fine print that penalises early adopters and knocks out most vegetation on farms from receiving credits.
The Government’s announcement prior to Christmas was a reconfirmation of what they had previously agreed to and generally aligned with what our industry groups/ HWEN proposed.
The promise of full sequestration credits under HWEN in the future is a red herring and a lie. Both the Government and industry groups have agreed to criteria like ‘additionality’, which knocks out most vegetation on farms being eligible.
Maybe the biggest hope is for native vegetation on farms to receive substantial credits for all values, not just sequestration in a revamped ETS. This was something the Government committed to follow up on when we raised it at our recent meeting with the (former) Prime Minister and ministers.
The emissions pricing and sequestration debacle has exposed major failings in our national advocacy voice. We can no longer have confidence in our industry leaders to provide full and accurate information on policies and regulations that directly impact farmers.
Our industry groups need to decide whether they are independent, faithful advocates of grassroots farmers. Or agents helping the Government roll out their policy agenda.
The sequestration credits debacle proves they can’t be both and a major revamp of farmer advocacy is well overdue.
Jamie McFadden is Groundswell NZ’s environmental spokesperson.
According to the most recent Rabobank Rural Confidence Survey, farmer confidence has inched higher, reaching its second highest reading in the last decade.
From 1 October, new livestock movement restrictions will be introduced in parts of Central Otago dealing with infected possums spreading bovine TB to livestock.
Phoebe Scherer, a technical manager from the Bay of Plenty, has won the 2025 Young Grower of the Year national title.
The Fencing Contractors Association of New Zealand (FCANZ) celebrated the best of the best at the 2025 Fencing Industry Awards, providing the opportunity to honour both rising talent and industry stalwarts.
Award-winning boutique cheese company, Cranky Goat Ltd has gone into voluntary liquidation.
As an independent review of the National Pest Management Plan for TB finds the goal of complete eradication by 2055 is still valide, feedback is being sought on how to finish the job.
OPINION: For years, the ironically named Dr Mike Joy has used his position at Victoria University to wage an activist-style…
OPINION: A mate of yours truly has had an absolute gutsful of the activist group SAFE.