Thursday, 20 September 2018 07:55

Wrangle over imported fruit tree stock

Written by  Nigel Malthus
Leaning Rock Orchard manager Peter Bennie shows where a small number of trees had to be destroyed because of the import accreditation issue. Leaning Rock Orchard manager Peter Bennie shows where a small number of trees had to be destroyed because of the import accreditation issue.

Protecting New Zealand’s biosecurity status is paramount in the wrangle over imported American fruit stock, says Summerfruit NZ chair Tim Jones.

Imports from the cultivar supplier Washington University Clean Plant Center Northwest (CPCNW) have been halted and thousands of trees either impounded or already destroyed, after the Ministry for Primary Industries said it could not be sure of their disease status because of non-compliance issues at the US facility.

Growers have challenged MPI in the High Court, which has directed MPI to reconsider and work with growers to develop more appropriate ways of managing its concerns. 

Jones, the general manager of the Central Otago cherry orchard company 45 South, says the affair raised several issues.

“From an industry point of view, the most important thing to protect is our biosecurity status, so we took the view that if there is any risk obviously the plants should be destroyed,” he told Rural News

“The bulk of the growers who had five trees or ten trees said ‘I don’t care, let’s just get rid of them. If there’s a risk let’s get them off the property’.”

However, the court case was taken by growers, such as nurseries, with more money at stake.

“So the industry groups – Summerfruit, Pipfruit – have sat to one side while that court case has been going on, just to see exactly where that’s going to shake out,” Jones says.

“Growers are saying to us ‘biosecurity is paramount, so we need to go into bat for them’.”

He says Summerfruit NZ would be “more than happy” for the impounded trees to be released if there was proved to be no risk.

Many of the affected trees have already been destroyed. Leaning Rock Orchard, Alexandra, had trial numbers of new varieties amounting to about a couple of dozen trees in total. 

Orchard manager Peter Bennie, indicating the gaps in the rows where trees were lifted and burned, emphasised that he was not criticising the way MPI handled the matter.

Jones says the bigger issue for the future is how to maintain a steady pathway of new genetic material coming into NZ. 

“This is closing the border at the moment for new stuff to come in. We’ve got an outdated import health standard that needs to be rebuilt so we can use modern technology.”

CPCNW is now saying it’s not interested in seeking re-accreditation for the NZ market. “That’s a concern, not just for summerfruit, but for pipfruit and any plant material that might be coming from that facility into NZ.”

Jones told Rural News that the problem for NZ is that it’s so small a market that suppliers find it uneconomic to deal with our accreditation requirements. 

“We fight that... with chemical companies, for example – fungicides, insecticides, that sort of thing. We’re such a small market that the cost of registration is prohibitive.”

More like this

Let’s be MPI’s eyes and ears

OPINION: The recent detection of Avian Influenza (AI), a low pathogenicity strain H7N6, at a free-range poultry farm in Otago has the agri sector focused on biosecurity. While the situation is cause for concern, the emphasis is on not panicking but remaining vigilant. The key message? Biosecurity is everyone’s responsibility.

Dairy, hort lead bounce back

The latest Ministry for Primary Industries report on the state of the primary sector shows that things are starting to look up after a rough 2023-24 season.

Pipfruit sector's huge economic impact

OPINION: When we set out to document the economic impact of New Zealand's apple and pear industry, we expected to see a trickle-down effect somewhere along the way.

Featured

Farmer honoured with New Zealand Order of Merit

Hauraki Coromandel farmer Keith Trembath was recently awarded the title of Member of the New Zealand Order of Merit (MNZM) in recognition of his contributions to public service, agriculture, and education.

RSE workers get immunised

Over 1,000 Recognised Seasonal Employer (RSE) workers in the Hawke’s Bay have now been immunised against measles.

National

Machinery & Products

Batten Buddy - cleverly simple

Stopping livestock from escaping their environment is a “must do” for any farmers or landowners and at times can seem…

U10 Pro Highland a step up

A few weeks after driving the CF MOTO U10 Pro ‘entry level’ model, we’ve had a chance to test the…

LC70 - A no-nonsense work horse

As most vehicle manufacturers are designing, producing and delivering machines with features that would take us into the next decade,…

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Dark ages

OPINION: Before we all let The Green Party have at it with their 'bold' emissions reduction plan, the Hound thought…

Rhymes with?

OPINION: The Feds' latest banking survey shows that bankers are even less popular with farmers than they used to be,…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter