Tuesday, 05 November 2019 12:55

Water reforms don’t come cheaply

Written by  David Anderson
Freshwater Leaders Group chair John Penno. Freshwater Leaders Group chair John Penno.

Farmers are not the only ones to be lumped with the heavy costs of the Government’s proposed new recommendations for freshwater.

Preliminary findings show that taxpayers will also pay profusely for preparing David Parker’s wide-eyed vision of “achieving a noticeable improvement in five years and restore our waterways within a generation”.

With the submission period now closed on the freshwater proposals, the primary sector waits in trepidation to see what exactly the final recommendations – and on-farm costs – will be.

In the meantime, the costs to the taxpayer of coming up with these proposed recommendations are already mounting.

An Official Information Act (OIA) request by Rural News has discovered that just one of the four advisory groups, established to provide advice and recommendations on freshwater reforms to the Government, has already accrued nearly $400,000 in “baseline and non-baseline” costs – up until October 1, 2019. 

Rural News’ OIA related only to the costs and makeup of the 16-member Freshwater Leaders Group (FLG) chaired by former Synlait founder John Penno. The FLG is just one of the four separate advisory groups established by the Government to come up with its proposed water reforms – alongside the Maori Freshwater Forum, Science and Technical Advisory Group and Essential Freshwater Regional Sector Water Group.

According to the Ministry for the Environment (MfE) OIA response, the FLG’s preliminary non baseline costs include “travel, accommodation, meeting costs, fees as well secretariat and professional support”. It added that the baseline costs are for MfE staff preparing reports, presenting at meetings and other work as needed.

However, these costs do not include the extensive round of ‘farmer consultation’ meetings held all around the country on the proposals, which will have racked up even more travel and accommodation costs.

“Please note that the above costs are based on received invoices and will change over time as more invoices are received,” MfE warned.

Not a bad earner

Rural News’ OIA also asked about the criteria, interview process and make-up of the panel that went into deciding the composition of the 16 member FLG.

“The Minister for the Environment and Minister of Agriculture asked the Ministry for the Environment to seek suggestions on their behalf for suitable people from relevant primary sector agencies and representatives,” MfE responded. 

“Ministers then assessed the candidates and selected a group of people… to ensure the success of the FLG and the Government’s Essential Freshwater programme.”

Some of this ‘selected’ group included many vocal farming critics such as the former Fish and Game boss Bryce Johnson; Environmental Defence Society executive director (former DoC head) Hugh Logan; freshwater campaigner Marnie Prickett; and Landcorp’s head of environment Alison Dewes.

According to MfE’s website, the FLG met 11 times in total from October 2018 until June 2019. 

Chair John Penno was paid a $1000 daily meeting fee, while group members were paid a daily meeting fee of $500 each.

“Note that not all FLG members have chosen to claim the fees,” MfE explained.

Farmer members Tom Lambie and Graham Gleeson claimed no fees, neither did Traci Houpapa and Beef + Lamb NZ executive Corina Jordan.

Chair John Penno claimed the most in daily fees at $18,000, Dewes claimed the next highest amount of $12,942, Logan was next at $11,500 and Prickett the fourth highest claimant at $9500.

More like this

No more muddying of the waters

Farmers will soon have an app to help them make better decisions about controlling erosion and reducing sediment entering New Zealand waterways.


In for the long haul

The coronavirus epidemic is going to have a bigger impact than people think it is, according to Massey University Professor of Agribusiness, Hamish Gow.

Coronavirus situation ‘dynamic’ – SFF

Silver Fern Farms is giving weekly reports to its suppliers to keep them abreast of what it describes as a ‘dynamic situation in China and one that could change very quickly’.


Southern treasure or trash?

A man who bought an opencast Southland lignite mine 18 years ago no longer sells the coal for fuel, but sings its praises as stock food, fertiliser and soil conditioner. 

» The RNG Weather Report

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound


Your old mate was disappointed, but not surprised to see a ‘study’ out of Otago University – quoted all over…

A dilemma

Your canine crusader reckons the fiercely anti GE, but pro sustainability Green Party has a dilemma on its hands, following…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter