Wednesday, 19 June 2019 10:55

Are we too dependent on China?

Written by  Pam Tipa
ANZ rural economist Susan Kilsby. ANZ rural economist Susan Kilsby.

Is New Zealand becoming too reliant on China as a customer for primary product exports?

Everyone is asking this question, says ANZ rural economist Susan Kilsby.

“The way I see it, yes we are selling a lot into one market. But it is a massive market with a lot of different moving parts in it,” she says. 

“So it is a little bit like selling into Europe – there are many different religions or cultures…. There’s a lot of differentiation within China.” 

Kilsby was commenting to Rural News on the latest ANZ Agri Focus Report entitled ‘Fine China or Fragile China?’.

She says NZ needs to be exposed more to Asia than to the developed markets because the economies in Asia are growing much more rapidly.

“So being exposed to Asia is a really good thing. It would probably be great if we were exposed to a few more countries to a greater degree than we are. But if we weren’t as exposed to China as we currently are the return back to farmers wouldn’t be as good.”

Kilsby adds that despite the warnings sounding about the global economy for a while, it is perhaps not impacting us so much here in NZ because we still have strong demand for our products. 

She also says that after the Global Financial Crisis we did not have the impact on our economy that many other economies had.

“We grew our exposure at that point to China which was growing rapidly while the global economy was not as strong. 

“We are reasonably well positioned at the moment, being exposed to Asia. It doesn’t come without its risks and some of that is regulatory and [some of it] access into China. It can flip on a dime for certain products. But it has certainly paid off for us so far.”

Kilsby says farmgate returns are quite strong across all sectors currently with the only headwinds being less certainty in the global economic situation. “There is never a whole lot of certainty but less at the moment with the majority of the major economies across the world slowing a little…. Lower GDPs and as a result central banks cutting interest rates to stimulate economies.

“But certainly from markets we are selling into at the moment we are still seeing good returns across the board.”

For the meat industry, many of those returns have been driven by diverting more product -- lamb and beef -- into China. In China, chain restaurants specialising in beef are growing in the big cities.

The Agrifocus report says the projected milk price of $6.25-$7.25/kgMS for the 2019-2020 season is more conservative than expected, but there are signs this will increase in future.  

“Milk prices for the coming season are on track to be stronger than the current season,” Kilsby says.

“Demand could be impacted by slowing global growth but global milk supply is expected to be contained which should support strong prices in the year ahead.”

NZ beef exports have held up well through the peak processing season, and beef exporters are benefitting from two strong markets: China and the United States. 

Investment in horticulture continues as returns from apples and kiwifruit outperform the rest of the sector.

 A strong start to the kiwifruit season has resulted in record export returns and for the first time gold fruit is expected to outperform green.  

“We’re seeing an increase in gold kiwifruit as more orchardists convert from green to gold,” Kilsby says.  

“Gold fruit matures earlier than green and it yields well which helps drive higher returns. While all gold has been picked the green harvest continues.”

» Connect with Rural News

More like this

China still hungry for NZ dairy

Demand for New Zealand dairy products should remain solid despite China’s mixed economic outlook, says Imre Speizer, Westpac.

Bleeding out NZ?

OPINION: By 2050 China will own New Zealand agriculture and with it our country’s future.

Yili’s ‘silk road’ under construction

Yili's takeover of Westland, the second-largest dairy enterprise in New Zealand, creates a ‘dairy silk road’ between Asia and NZ, says Yili Group chief executive Jianqiu Zhang.

Trump tactics

Kiwi farmers are not the only ones nervous about their future as a result of politicians throwing them under the harvester.

» The RNG Weather Report


A big future ahead

Age hasn't been a barrier for young vegetable grower of the year Austin Singh Purewal.


Sheep and beef doing its bit

No increase in stock numbers in the sheep and beef sector is anticipated as the industry moves towards carbon neutrality, says Beef + Lamb NZ head of nutrition Fiona Windle.

Fonterra lifts milk price

Good news for Fonterra farmers – the co-op is increasing its 2019-20 forecast farmgate milk price by 30c/kgMS.

» Connect with Rural News

» Connect with Rural News

» The RNG Weather Report

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Chipping in

The Hound was intrigued to read an article recently, on the Newsroom website, that shows that Education Minister Chris ‘Chippy’…

I'm alright

This old mutt has been contacted by many concerned individuals about the role the former Synlait boss John Penno is…


» Connect with Rural News