Thursday, 01 December 2022 12:55

Over regulated and under stress

Written by  Barbara Kuriger
Processes to enact winter grazing regulations which took effect on November 1, aren’t in place yet. Processes to enact winter grazing regulations which took effect on November 1, aren’t in place yet.

OPINION: The consultation period for the Government’s emissions pricing plan for agriculture is closing as I write this.

Since its unveiling last month, Labour’s plan based on the He Waka Eke Noa’s partnership report but heavily tweaked, has drawn nothing but derision and a stock standard refusal from farming sectors and entire regions.

With just cause.

One size regulations like the above are not fit for purpose — never have been and never will be.

Moreover, it joined the raft of regulations (proposed and enacted) on our rural communities and ag sector.

Since Labour took office, I’ve been at a loss to see why agencies like the Ministry for the Environment (MfE) and Ministry for Primary Industries continue to push these ‘one-size fits all’ policies.

Regulating, without any thought given to the impacts of what they’re introducing or how they will be implemented.

A recent example is the many southern farmers refusing to apply for resource consents from their regional councils in order to comply with MfE’s intensive winter grazing regulations.

That’s because the processes, to enact the regulations which took effect on November 1, aren’t in place yet.

We know they want change, but the way things are being done, makes even a dog’s breakfast look appetising.

When I began dairy farming in systems were similar. But even back then, there were differences. Dairy farming was largely pasture-based without a lot of bought in feed and limited nitrogen fertiliser.

Today NZ farms are either bovine or ovine, plus a mix of deer, alpacas and other animals. Pork and poultry farmers have their own challenges.

In the past fortnight, I’ve visited three extremely different farming operations.

A beef lot where all the feed is brought in, a sheep and beef operation mixed with production forestry and finally a pasture-based biological dairy system with few purchased inputs. So from harvesting and carrying food on the first farm, to cows, beef and sheep doing the harvesting on the other two.

All farms are part of catchment or sub-catchment areas, with wideranging operations, allowing rural communities to work together solving their unique environmental needs.

It makes absolute sense and is a suitable place for iwi and farmers to solve the challenges evolving from our landbased systems.

How the varied industries involved in He Waka Eke Noa arrived at a model which incorporated not only the above systems, but a range of others including horticulture without any ruminant animals, is quite a thought process.

Especially when farmers just want to put on their boots in the morning and, after taking care their animals, plant a shelter belt of trees rather than ticking boxes (virtually or literally) to comply with the next chore on the Government’s job list.

After many years in the industry, I know all farmers, no matter what part of the sector, are under stress – stress borne from nonsensical ideas with no idea of the impact on our food producing families.

Never has there been so much red tape to contend with, and so much contempt for those who tend the land yet contribute more than 50% to our economy. It’s heart-breaking.

Barbara Kuriger is National’s MP for Taranaki- King Country.

More like this

DairyNZ chair wants cross-party deal

New DairyNZ chair Tracy Brown says bipartisan agreement among political parties on emissions pricing and freshwater regulations would greatly help farmers.

Positive signs, says McClay

First up to the podium at the recent Tractor and Machinery Association (TAMA) Conference in Wellington, Minster for Agriculture, Todd McClay, reflected on a difficult 12 months, but hinted at signs that things were turning the corner, saying “when ag does well, New Zealand does well”.

Replacing farms with forests?

A horror story - that’s how Federated Farmers describes new research looking at forestry conversions’ impact on water quality.

Overreach

OPINION: When Groundswell showed up in the 'advocacy hub' at Fieldays alongside the same groups that brought you He Waka Eke Noa, the Hound feared the ginger group had been brought into the woke fold and given the old rubber ring.

One levy

OPINION: Industry-good bodies have had a torrid time recently, with some facing backlash from farmers particularly over their stance on emissions pricing and He Waka Eke Noa.

Featured

Fruit fly discovery 'concerning'

Horticulture New Zealand (HortNZ) says that discovery of a male Oriental fruit fly on Auckland’s North Shore is a cause for concern for growers.

Fonterra updates earnings

Fonterra says its earnings for the 2025 financial year are anticipated to be in the upper half of its previously forecast earnings range of 40-60 cents per share.

Nedap NZ launch

Livestock management tech company Nedap has launched Nedap New Zealand.

National

Certainty welcomed

There's been very little reaction to the government science reform announcement, with many saying the devil will be in the…

Science 'deserves more funding'

A committee which carried out the review into New Zealand's science system says the underinvestment will continue to compromise the…

Machinery & Products

Landpower win global award

Christchurch-headquartered Landpower and its Claas Harvest Centre dealerships has taken out the Global After Sales Excellence award in Germany, during…

Innovation, new products galore

It has been a year of new products and innovation at Numedic, the Rotorua-based manufacturer and exporter of farm dairy…

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

No buyers

OPINION: Australian dairy is bracing for the retirement of an iconic dairy brand.

RIP Kitkat V

OPINION: Another sign that the plant-based dairy fallacy is unravelling and that nothing beats dairy-based products.

» Connect with Dairy News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter