Wednesday, 28 October 2020 11:13

An exercise in futility

Written by  Simon Couper
Simon Couper. Simon Couper.

Former Fonterra Shareholders Council (SHC) chair and Waipu farmer Simon Couper puts his views on why the recent review of the council’s functions was a futile exercise.

This is the first article of his five-part series:

OPINION: Reviewing the SHC is like debating the performance of the orchestra after the captain of the ship has steered into an iceberg.

The SHC has no input to investment and strategy decisions of Fonterra and no mandate to change them once they were made.

A review of the SHC is a distraction and waste of resources and will tell us little or nothing about how we got to the position we are in or options we have for going forward from here.

What we should be reviewing is Fonterra’s strategy.

As shareholders we need to understand the key elements of strategy in a commercially competitive environment and how to measure performance.

Over the years, strategy presentations have been delivered on what Fonterra is doing and where it would be going. As shareholders we have watched and invested our faith and our capital, but for whatever reason the delivery has most often fallen short of the promise.

We know there is excellence within Fonterra, but for different reasons, the mirage of value-added returns have smothered performance and clouded our recognition of Fonterra’s core strategic capabilities.

We have read the statements in the press from commentators, such as, “culture”, “Fonterra is doing everything for everyone” and “Fonterra is stuck in the middle”. But what do they mean in a commercial context?

After eight years in the SHC, my understanding of how Fonterra formed its strategy was as much a perplexing mystery as when I started.

If there was one thing I could change about the input I had in that eight years, it would have been to educate and improve my understanding of strategy in a commercially competitive environment and then make sure my fellow shareholders were given the same opportunity.

Last year I completed an MBA through Massey University. The Massey MBA is strong on Leadership, Strategy and International Strategy and Leadership. 

As Miles Davis said, “knowledge is freedom and ignorance is slavery”. I have found that a rigorous education of strategy has afforded me a more complete understanding of the risks our industry faces and the opportunities there are available.

The NZ dairy industry is not a completely free competitive market as there are distortions presented by geography and legislation. However, the industry now has enough competitors and visibility to demonstrate different strategic approaches and how they can be measured.

The fitness of Fonterra’s performance and strategy can be gauged by understanding the performance and strategies of competing firms within the NZ dairy industry.

It is my aim in five articles over the next five issues to:

identify the different competitive strategies within the dairy industry

understand how strategic advantage is protected and measure performance

understand strategies for succeeding internationally

identify Fonterra’s core strategic capabilities

outline the recognised elements a successful strategy most often contains.

Fonterra’s recent profit announcement is good news and we should take heart. But we also need to understand exactly where we are going and how we are going to get there.

I don’t profess to know it all and it is often easy to counter complex arguments that have been presented simply. But as can be said about many organisations, “you get the governance you deserve”. The purpose is to present a perspective from which to view and question the strategic performance of our cooperative.

It will take you less than ten minutes to read.

More like this

Strategies at play

Former Fonterra Shareholders Council chairman and Waipu farmer Simon Couper looks at the strategies of Fonterra's competitors to see how the co-op can strengthen its own strategies.

Quiet offload

OPINION: Fonterra has quietly offloaded its 50% stake in Agrifeeds, a major importer of palm kernel expeller into New Zealand.


New investment in spirulina production

The Ministry for Primary Industries (MPI) Sustainable Food & Fibres Futures Fund will invest in a project to assess the viability of larger scale production of spirulina in New Zealand.


Lely offerings for the future

Dutch robotic specialist Lely launched a new farm management application called Horizon at its recent Future Farm Days 2020.


Miraka picks up awards

Taupo-based Maori dairy company Miraka took the top honours at this year’s Biosecurity Awards.

Wyeth ready for new challenge

The chief executive-elect of Yili-owned Westland Milk Products Richard Wyeth says he’s looking forward to the challenge of running the…

Machinery & Products

Mixer makes feeding easy

Coolbreene Trust near Taupo is a large-scale dairy operation farming 1150ha, including run-off blocks, within a 10km radius of its…

More colour to light range

Originally available with amber lenses only, Narva’s ‘Geomax’ Heavy Duty LED Strobe Beacon light range has been upgraded with the…

State funding for recycling

Having declared in July that all farm plastics sold in New Zealand will have to be recycled or reused, the…

» The RNG Weather Report

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

Avoiding listeria

OPINION: The company that makes dairy products under “The Collective” brand, and which copped a nearly $500,000 fine for failing…

Greenpeace seeing red

OPINION: Still with Greenpeace, the organisation’s push for a price on agricultural greenhouse gas emissions is gaining momentum since the…

» Connect with Dairy News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter