Banks should act sensibly when dealing with debt-ridden farmers, says economist Cameron Bagrie.
The latest ANZ Agri Focus reports a huge range of positives for the sector, yet the bank’s agricultural economist, Susan Kilsby, says dairy farmer confidence is the lowest they have seen in more than 20 years.
The biggest thing impacting farmer confidence is the uncertainty about Government regulations on environmental legislation, she says.
“Also, costs are rising and farmers have high debt levels. Farmers have had long periods of interest-only lending but the banks are looking for principal repayments on loans.”
Kilsby says ANZ bank sees a positive outlook for the dairy sector and as a result has revised its payout forecast upwards by 15c to $7.15/kgMS. This is because the outlook for commodity prices is strong and the NZ$ is expected to remain low.
ANZ says the Fonterra payout for the 2019-20 season is in the range of $6.55 - $7.55 and Kilsby says while this seems plausible, the chances of this hitting the bottom end of the range is now looking unlikely. The bank says milk price futures for the 2020-21 season have gained more than 25 cents over the past month to trade above $6.50/kgMS. Farmers trading this contract are looking for a degree of certainty in their future income stream, the bank says.
Meanwhile the ANZ Agri Focus reports that global milk production remains subdued which will support better dairy commodity prices. ANZ says that while commodity prices have remained relatively stable in recent years they have not been high enough to encourage expansion in the big milk producing regions of Europe and the United States.
European milk production is up by only 0.4 of 1%, while US production is up by a “tiny point one of a percent”. Cow and heifer numbers in the US are also down.
The Australian dairy industry has been hit by ongoing droughts and water costs and this has hampered the viability of the key milk producing state Victoria.
Australia is now only a minor player in the international dairy market, says ANZ. Only about 25% of Australia’s milk supply is now exported, whereas 20 years ago almost half its milk was exported.
Overall ANZ says assuming global demand holds up the outlook for dairy products remains robust.
The bank says the NZ season is off to a strong start.