Tuesday, 11 April 2017 07:55

One Plan in tatters

Written by 
Manawatu Federated Farmers president James Stewart says farmers are frustrated. Manawatu Federated Farmers president James Stewart says farmers are frustrated.

“We just want to get on with it,” say Manawatu dairy farmers reacting to news that Horizons Regional Council’s One Plan implementation has effectively been ruled unlawful by the Environment Court.

This decision promises more delays and uncertainty over resource consents in the region.

The Environmental Defence Society (EDS) and Fish and Game (F&G) challenged Horizons’ implementation in the Environment Court; the court agreed.

In the process the court has strongly criticised Horizons’ approach and their failure to work with EDS and F&G who, before they took court action, had complained about the process. The court says such an attitude on the part of a law making and law administering body is not acceptable.

The president of Manawatu Federated Farmers, dairy farmer James Stewart, says farmers in the region are frustrated and face more uncertainty.

They don’t know where they are with their costings and consents, he says.

“I was talking to a dairy farmer the other day and they just want to get on with it. They want to move on, get consented and do the right thing. They are concerned about what it means for those who already have consents.”

For its part the council claims there is no problem with existing consents, but as Gary Taylor of EDS asks, if the implementation process was unlawful where does that leave consents?

Stewart says it is all frustrating for farmers who are fed up with the drawn-out One Plan process.

“Farmers have been doing a lot of work on this and we have seen good results, such as the reduction in N leaching and improvement in water quality, yet it keeps going on.

“Fish and Game [told me] they had nothing against farming and that the appeal was about a point of law. To me that’s a cop-out and a contradiction; of course it affects farmers.”

Stewart says farmers have been hard-out to improve the environment but are now nearing the point of asking “why bother?” Dairy farmers feel they are being used as a political football and that’s not a nice feeling.

He says the court ruling is complex and detailed and it will take time to fully analyse the details and work out what action his organisation may take. Meanwhile farmers face uncertainty and disruption.

When the One Plan was finally approved, there were concerns about its workability and the council set up the implementation plan which in effect tried to by-pass some of the actual intent of the plan. The Environment Court says the correct course of action would have been to initiate a ‘plan change’. But the council feared this could have taken years.

Ironically, in the light of this judgement, Horizons may have to do a plan change, but if it attempts to go for anything less than the status quo, FAG and EDS will almost certainly oppose such a move.

Also criticised by the court is ‘guidance material’ provided by DairyNZ to help the council determine its consents. The court says important parts of this material are not consistent with, or fall short of, or are even contrary to, the declarations they consider should have been made.

The court has also taken a swipe at the council in its implementation for focusing on economic impacts on individuals. “That is not a reason to manipulate or pervert plan implementation,” says the court.

Since its inception more than a decade ago the One Plan has always been complicated and dogged with controversy. It was ‘sold’ to the public as a simple solution which incorporated a myriad of planning documents.

Ten years on, the One Plan is regarded by many as a bit of dog and the present decision will likely spark at least another two-three years of uncertainty for land users – especially dairy farmers.

More like this

Strong uptake of good wintering practices

DairyNZ has seen a significant increase in the number of farmers improving their wintering practices, which results in a higher standard of animal care and environmental protection.

Better animal genetic gain system

A governance group has been formed, following extensive sector consultation, to implement the recommendations from the Industry Working Group's (IWG) final report and is said to be forming a 'road map' for improving New Zealand's animal genetic gain system.

OSPRI's costly software upgrade

Animal disease management agency OSPRI has announced sweeping governance changes as it seeks to recover from the expensive failure of a major software project.

Musical chairs

OPINION: DairyNZ's director elections has seen scientist Jacqueline Rowarth re-elected for another three-year term.

Featured

Massey Research Field Day attracts huge interest

More than 200 people turned out on Thursday, November 21 to see what progress has been made on one of NZ's biggest and most comprehensive agriculture research programmes on regenerative agriculture.

Expo set to wow again

Stellar speakers, top-notch trade sites, innovation, technology and connections are all on offer at the 2025 East Coast Farming Expo being once again hosted in Wairoa in February.

A year of global challenges

As a guest of the Italian Trade Association, Rural News Group Machinery Editor Mark Daniel took the opportunity to make an early November dash to Bologna to the 46th EIMA exhibition.

National

OSPRI's costly software upgrade

Animal disease management agency OSPRI has announced sweeping governance changes as it seeks to recover from the expensive failure of…

Machinery & Products

BA Pumps expand

Cambridge based BA Pumps & Sprayers, specialists in New Zealand-made spraying equipment, has acquired Tokoroa Engineering’s product range, including the…

Entries open for innovation award

Fieldays and its renowned Innovation Awards are celebrating their 57th year, marking a longstanding tradition in the agricultural calendar, with…

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

Chinese strategy

OPINION: Fonterra may have sold its dairy farms in China but the appetite for collaboration with the country remains strong.

Not fair

OPINION: The Listener's latest piece on winter grazing among Southland dairy farmers leaves much to be desired.

» Connect with Dairy News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter