Picking winners?
OPINION: Every time politicians come up with an investment scheme where they're going to have a crack at 'picking winners' with our money, the Hound cringes.
“That NPS would have controlled increases in livestock intensity. The national dairy herd has since increased by one million cows producing effluent equivalent to 14 million people, most of which is discharged to land, much of which is leaches into waterways,” she told the Environmental Defence Society ‘Tipping Points’ conference in Auckland.
“Nine years on, nitrate levels are still increasing in 55% of monitored waterways. In 2015 over 60% of monitored river sites are graded poor or very poor for swimming.
“In some areas, dairy conversions or battery beef lots or more intensive farming systems using irrigation or intensive winter grazing on steep slopes are doing enormous damage to our rivers and estuaries. Effects are spreading out to sea blocking photosynthesis of kelp beds and clogging up sands with fine silts.”
Labour plans to introduce a new National Policy Statement (NPS) for Freshwater Management based on an original NPS drafted by a board of inquiry chaired by Environment Court judge David Sheppard in 2010.
Sheppard said an increase in land use intensity such as a large dairy conversion or putting in a beef lot or irrigation should always require a resource consent so that a point of control exists to prevent intensification of land use making water quality worse, Labour’s spokesman on water David Parker told Dairy News.
Parker acknowledged this is already the case for dairy in many regions.
“In respect of the dairy platform there are parts of Southland with inadequate controls on winter grazing; some sediment loads and nutrient loads from winter break feeding are beyond the pale.”
Ardern said the Canterbury medical officer of health has told mothers not to feed babies bottled milk from South Canterbury water bores because nitrates are so high they disrupt oxygen flow around the body – ‘blue baby syndrome’.
The Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment has said there is a “clear link between expanding dairy farming and increasing stress on water quality. Even with the best practice mitigation the large scale conversion of more land to dairy farming will generally result in more and more degraded fresh water”.
“To some in politics this doesn’t appear to be a threat worth worrying about,” Ardern told the conference. “They think the environment and public should simply carry the cost. The past decade of political inaction has legitimised this pollution and current land use policies have institutionalised it.
“The current government’s first replacement NPS required a low wadeable standard which most New Zealanders ridiculed. They then proposed fencing of mid country waterways many years from now, sometimes not until 2030.
“Under pressure in their ninth year of government they have now introduced a draft swimmable target which has been widely criticised by scientists. They shifted the goalpost on E.coli.
“The NPS says a river is swimmable even if livestock effluent and nutrient pollution or low flows from irrigation extraction are causing excessive slime growth.
“That is not what I call swimmable, not even for my friends the eels.
“Their standards allow nitrates at levels perilously close to toxic for plants and macro-invertebrates. They use floods as cover to ignore adverse test results for up to 20% of the time.”
