What Would Synlait Be Worth to Fonterra or a2 Milk?
Speculation of a possible joint move by Fonterra and a2 Milk to buy Synlait raises a much bigger strategic question, says agribusiness expert Dr Nic Lees.
The co-op is forecasting a farmgate milk price of $6.30-$6.60/kgMS.
Chief executive Miles Hurrell told a media briefing last week that good demand for ingredients was coming from Asia, including Greater China.
On the supply front, milk growth has slowed due to trying weather in some large milk producing regions.
Australia’s milk production is forecast to be down 7-9% on last season due to drought; in the EU, growth has slowed and is forecast to be less than 1% on last year.
Hurrell says for Fonterra farmers, the strong dry weather has also impacted milk production.
The co-op two weeks ago downgraded its milk forecast for the season from 1530 million kgMS to 1510 million kgMS for 2018-19. This is slightly above last season’s collections of 1505 million kgMS, a season also impacted by poor onfarm conditions.
Hurrell notes that milk price is an important metric for the co-op. “We are owned by 10,000 farming families and their livelihood depends on the milk price.”
Fonterra is promising farmers more accurate forecasting -- a tough task given volatility in weather and geopolitics. “This makes forecasting difficult; that’s why we have resorted to ranges in our forecast,” Hurrell says.
Hurrell last week outlined the priorities for the co-op for the second half of the 2018-19 financial year: to meet the earnings guidance, deliver on the three-point plan and fundamentally reset the business so it can achieve sustainable earnings.
“We have a forecast farmgate milk price of $6.30-$6.60/kgMS but we also have to meet our earnings guidance range of 15-25 cents per share,” says Hurrell.
Fonterra’s three-point plan involves taking stock of the business and reviewing its business portfolio, getting the basics right and improving its forecasting.
“We’ve made good progress so far and we will continue to take these steps in the second half to firm up our foundations and strengthen our balance sheet,” says Hurrell.
“The second half will also see us continuing the work on developing a new strategy to support a much-needed change in direction. We are doing the right things but it’s clear more is needed to lift our performance. We need to simplify and improve the co-op so we can grow value.”
