What Would Synlait Be Worth to Fonterra or a2 Milk?
Speculation of a possible joint move by Fonterra and a2 Milk to buy Synlait raises a much bigger strategic question, says agribusiness expert Dr Nic Lees.
The revision follows Fonterra’s reduction of its forecast earnings for the year ending July 2019.
“In our view this indicates that the cooperative has structural issues it needs to address to retain the defensive traits that have underscored its historically strong business profile,” Fitch says.
The cooperative’s current review will be crucial in this, it says.
Fitch says it “is positive for bondholders” that Fonterra has said it will not pay an interim dividend, that any decisions on full-year dividend will be made at the end of the financial year and that its dividend policy is under review.
This “continues to reinforce Fitch’s expectation that Fonterra will prioritise the strength of its balance sheet overpayment to farmer shareholders”.
Regarding structural issues, Fitch says “the effect that volatility in the dairy market and other industry issues in specific geographic regions continue to have on Fonterra’s profits indicates there are structural issues within the cooperative, which limit its ability to absorb these effects”.
Fitch says the cooperative is committed to reducing leverage and reviewing its portfolio.
“We believe asset sales are critical for Fonterra to return its metrics to a level in line with its current rating, given the impact the structural issues continue to have on Fonterra’s ability to organically deleverage.”
Any delay in the expected $800 million asset sales will put pressure on Fonterra’s rating.
Fitch notes Fonterra is a world leader in dairy exports representing about 15% in the global market including a 42% share in whole milk powder.
And it is New Zealand’s largest dairy producer collecting 82% of the country’s milk supply in the 2017-18 season. – Pam Tipa
