increase font size
BLNZ chair James Parsons (pictured) says it's time for the sheep and beef sector to pull together and focus on the future.
The results of the remit votes at Beef + Lamb NZ's recent annual meeting must surely be the final nail in the coffin of the meat sector ginger group MIE.
The two remits put up by MIE at the BLNZ meeting – one to fund the lobby group and the other to replace the two meat processor appointees to BLNZ board with MIE members – both failed to garner any more than 25% support.
BLNZ chair James Parsons says it's time for the sheep and beef sector to pull together and focus on the future. MIE won't like this message, but he is actually right.
There is no doubt, as Parsons has also noted, that MIE is made up of passionate and committed farmers who are pushing for a better sector. However, despite this passion and commitment, they have not succeeded in convincing the majority of red meat producers to support them or their cause.
MIE's Pathways report – which, among other things, strongly promoted the Newco model and merger of Silver Fern Farms and Alliance Group – was firmly rejected when SFF farmer shareholders overwhelmingly voted in favour of the merger with Chinese investor Shanghai Maling.
After this vote, many of the lobby group's leaders and members recognised they had lost the battle and decided to move on.
MIE's claims that the votes for both the SFF decision and BLNZ remits are somehow void due to the low turnout of farmers who actually cast their ballots is ridiculous and facile. That's democracy, and if farmers didn't bother to vote – then so be it. It would be like the Government dismissing the result of the recent flag referendum because fewer than 100% of New Zealanders bothered to cast their votes.
MIE cannot realistically complain that it has not had financial support from BLNZ – even if it was given begrudgingly.
In all, BLNZ has provided around $297,000 to the group. There was $40,000 for farmer awareness meetings when it first started. In April 2014 another $20,000 was provided for MIE's business plan and funding application and then, in July 2014, another $237,000 for its Pathways Report and communications strategy.
MIE has had a fair crack and it is time the group moved on. Continuing to argue it cause and throw rocks at the sector from the sidelines will only end up seeing its legacy further tarnished.
OPINION: When I moved to Marlborough two decades ago, I found countless lines of tidy vines, neatly mowed and carefully sprayed, with diligent conventional practices interspersed with the odd organic or cover-cropping outlier, like Te Whare Ra.
OPINION: The Government has been seeking industry feedback on its proposed amendments to a range of Resource Management Act (RMA) national direction instruments.
OPINION: The Government's decision to stop local authorities going ahead with reviews of district and regional plans makes sense for several reasons.
OPINION: Good times are coming back for the primary industries. From sentiment expressed at Fieldays to the latest rural confidence survey results, all indicate farmer confidence at a near-record high.
OPINION: Two reports out last week confirm that the worst may be over for pastoral farmers.
According to the latest Federated Farmers banking survey, farmers are more satisfied with their bank and less under pressure, however, the sector is well short of confidence levels seen last decade.
Farmer confidence has taken a slight dip according to the final Rabobank rural confidence survey for the year.
Former Agriculture Minister and Otaki farmer Nathan Guy has been appointed New Zealand’s Special Agricultural Trade Envoy (SATE).
Alliance Group has commissioned a new heat pump system at its Mataura processing plant in Southland.
Fonterra has slashed another 50c off its milk price forecast as global milk flows shows no sign of easing.
Meat processors are hopeful that the additional 15% tariff on lamb exports to the US will also come off.
OPINION: The release of the Natural Environment Bill and Planning Bill to replace the Resource Management Act is a red-letter day…
OPINION: Federated Farmers has launched a new campaign, swapping ‘The Twelve Days of Christmas’ for ‘The Twelve Pests of Christmas’ to…
