Wednesday, 16 December 2015 15:53

Extremists’ views place heavy cost on farming and consumers

Written by  Jacqueline Rowarth
Jacqueline Rowarth. Jacqueline Rowarth.

The 'businessman' who threatened the NZ dairy industry with 1080 contamination in baby formula if use of the pest-killing poison wasn't terminated apparently intended to gain economic advantage for a product of his own.

If he is found guilty, the maximum sentence for the charges is 14 years imprisonment. At the arrest, Police Commissioner Mike Bush stated: "Today's development sends a
clear message on how seriously we take threats of this criminal nature and how we will use every resource, no matter how long it takes, to [meet them]."

The total cost to the police by October was over $3 million; to the dairy industry it was considerably higher because of extra testing and security measures. Estimates for the security guards for Fonterra alone are over $15 million – money that could otherwise have been returned to the shareholders.

At the time, public sentiment appeared to indicate less understanding of the 'businessman's' action motivated by financial gain than of activism against 1080. Outrage was high at greed endangering the dairy sector; ideology is easier to comprehend.

Now the dairy industry is dealing with activism by Farmwatch and SAFE against production systems, at the same time as these groups are claiming victory in a change in sow management.

NZ pork producers now have the highest standards for sow breeding units in the world. They also have a declining share of the pork product market in NZ, as more and more consumers buy imported, cheaper, pork products. Just like egg producers, pig farmers are doing what society said it wanted, and watching consumers choose product from production systems they have said they don't want – because of price.

For dairy it is difficult to understand what SAFE really wants. Certainly there is never any excuse for cruelty – not with farm animals, pets, children or partners. Certainly NZ has strict codes of animal welfare to which most animal handlers adhere. And the petfood company involved in the bobby-calf issue has been upfront in saying that the behaviour filmed by SAFE was not acceptable which was why the people involved had been sacked.

But SAFE has still run the 'dairy cruelty' advertisement in the UK newspaper The Guardian.

Dairy product exports to the UK are small. Social media, however, has a big reach and the advertisement is damaging to our reputation. If the image 'takes off', questions will be asked about European production systems; because all dairy production systems involve separating mother and offspring, answers won't be easy to find.

The bigger agenda for SAFE could be a drive towards veganism – to give up animal production systems altogether. Producing enough high quality protein for the ever-increasing global population would be the challenge, and improved cropping technologies would be needed in order to minimise environmental impact on soil and atmosphere. The problem with crops is that they need nutrients and water, and must be protected from pests and diseases – as do animals. The animals, however, yield high quality energy and protein and can be grown almost anywhere whereas crops are restricted to cultivatable land.

Adding poultry into the diet with eggs and meat increases the quality of human intake efficiently, but grain is still needed, and grain is a crop.

There are no easy answers.

In Auckland protein shakes are being consumed instead of milk - with no comprehension of where the protein in the shake originates (usually whey).

The fundamental problem is clearly lack of understanding about how food is produced and the innate nature of the stewardship and husbandry relationship with the soil, plant and animal.

Reputational damage used to result in 'pistols at dawn'. The modern day equivalent might not be 14 years imprisonment, but should be investigated; the potential cost to the global dairy industry is high.

• Jacqueline Rowarth is professor of agribusiness, The University of Waikato.

More like this

Bikinis in cowshed

OPINION: An animal activist organisation is calling for an investigation into the use of dairy cows in sexuallly explicit content posted on social media and adult entertainment subscription site OnlyFans.

The politics of climate change

OPINION: The Financial Times, a major international newspaper, featured New Zealand on its front page at the beginning of June. It wasn't for the right reasons.

The social licence to operate

OPINION: In the 2023 election, 77.5% of the 3.69 million people eligible to vote took the privilege of making their wishes known about the governance of New Zealand.

Featured

LIC ends year with $30.6m profit

Herd improvement company LIC has ended the 2024-25 financial year in a strong position - debt-free and almost quadrupling its net profit.

Farmers back Government pause on RMA plan changes

There's been widespread support from the primary sector for the Government's move to put the brakes on local authorities to do any more work on planning changes ahead of major changes to the Resource Management Act (RMA).

Flood-hit Tasman farms begin long recovery

People affected by the recent two severe flood events in the Tasman district are weary and exhausted trying to deal with the devastation on their farms and orchards, according to the head of the Rural Support Trust (RST) in the region.

National

Machinery & Products

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Trop de Paris!

OPINION: Your old mate's ear has been chewed off recently by farmers voicing their displeasure with the National Party, particularly…

NZ vs Aussie beef

OPINION: Your old mate hears that at a recent China Business Summit, PM Christopher Luxon delivered a none-too-subtle "could try…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter