Thursday, 16 February 2012 08:07

Purchase Group welcomes Crafar decision

Written by 

The Crafar Farms Purchase Group says today's High Court decision confirms its view that Shanghai Pengxin's purchase of the Crafar Farms brought no additional economic benefit to New Zealand.

Group spokesman Alan McDonald says Justice Miller's judgment to set aside the decision of the Ministers to approve the sale was welcomed by the group and confirmed the reasons for their opposition to the Shanghai Pengxin bid.

"Our view was that Shanghai Pengxin's offer brought no real economic benefit to New Zealand and it was not in the best interests of New Zealanders. It is reassuring that a High Court judge has come to a similar conclusion and set aside the Ministers' approval," says Mr McDonald.

Bell Gully Lawyer David Cooper, who represented the Purchase Group, says: "The judgment confirms that the Ministers and the OIO misapplied the Overseas Investment Act and materially overstated the benefits to New Zealand arising from the transaction. The Judge has therefore set aside the decision to grant consent and has required the Ministers to follow the test in the Act."

McDonald said paragraph 57 in Justice Miller's judgement was the one at the heart of the matter for the Purchase Group.

That paragraph states: "The error was not a mere technicality. No one suggested that the farms are likely to remain in their present unsatisfactory state, whoever purchases them. Any solvent purchaser can be expected to bring their production up to its potential. That being so, the economic benefits caused by the overseas investment were materially overstated in the OIO's recommendation."

McDonald said the Purchase Group and its legal team were now taking time to fully consider the details of Justice Miller's decision.

More like this

Crafar saga should prompt review

A High Court decision that will cause Government ministers to reconsider the sale of the former Crafar farms could improve investment certainty in the long run, says Federated Farmers.

Legal hurdle looms

Sir Michael Fay's legal challenge to the sale of Crafar Farms to a Chinese buyer will put Overseas Investment Office processes through the judicial wringer, says Federated Farmers.

Featured

$52,500 fine for effluent mismanagement

A Taupiri farming company has been convicted and fined $52,500 in the Hamilton District Court for the unlawful discharge of dairy effluent into the environment.

Ospri brings Bovine TB testing in-house

The move to bring bovine TB testing in-house at Ospri officially started this month, as a team of 37 skilled and experienced technicians begin work with the disease eradication agency.

National

Machinery & Products

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Arable advocacy?

OPINION: Spare a thought for the arable farmer, squeezed on one side by soft global prices and on the other…

Gaslight much?

OPINION: Labour leader Chris 'Chippy' Hipkins is carrying on the world-class gaslighting of the nation that he and his cohorts…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter