Wednesday, 17 December 2014 00:00

Fonterra chair admits bungle over false botulism scare

Written by 
John Wilson: “We should have handled some things differently.” John Wilson: “We should have handled some things differently.”

FONTERRA CHAIRMAN John Wilson admits the co-op should have handled some aspects of last year’s false botulism scare differently, but he says the co-op’s food safety has been proven world-class.

 Wilson was commenting on the final report from the independent inquiry into last year’s false WPC80 botulism scare. The report found shortcomings in the co-op’s traceability system and crisis management.

Wilson told Rural News the findings were “similar” to Fonterra’s own investigation report. “What is pleasing is that the recall had no food safety issues; it was a false alarm. “We should have handled some things differently… but overall our food safety is world-leading.”

The inquiry team was headed by Miriam Dean QC and assisted by Tony Nowell and Dr Anne Astin; Professor Alan Reilly was an independent peer reviewer.

It notes that having notified MPI, Fonterra had “no well-prepared (or reviewed or rehearsed) group crisis plan to implement, including crisis communications (particularly in social media)”.

Fonterra took until 18 August to trace all the affected products, “a seriously deficient effort,” it says.

“Fonterra did not effectively co-ordinate its actions with those of the ministry, Danone and the Government during the crisis. Fonterra’s communications were neither well conceived nor co-ordinated and lacked a tone that encouraged consumer trust and loyalty.”

The report also finds that the Ministry of Primary Industries did not have a coherent crisis plan for a food incident that it could implement straight away after receiving notification of C. botulinum.

It notes that the ministry’s response was hampered by Fonterra’s late notification overstating the certainty of C. botulinum and by Fonterra’s drawn-out and deficient tracing.

The report gives MPI credit for many aspects of its response, “but it should have had better-documented decisionmaking processes, used more rigorous science-based risk assessment and co-ordinated better with the industry to avoid unnecessary confusion among consumers and others”.

Primary Industries Minister Nathan Guy says the report is a “very robust piece of analysis.” “The rigour and conclusions of the report, and the actions of key players since the incident, should further strengthen confidence in New Zealand’s world class food safety system.”

 Fonterra chief executive Theo Spierings says food safety and quality are its number one priority.   

“At the time of the recall, we did what was right based on the evidence we had.  It was subsequently confirmed that the recalled WPC80 did not present a health risk,” says Spierings.

More like this

Fonterra's in good shape

Fonterra released its interim results last month, showing a continuation of the strong earnings performance delivered by the co-op through the 2023 financial year. Here’s what Fonterra chair Peter McBride and chief executive Miles Hurrell said about the results…

China trade

OPINION: Last week's revelation that data relating to New Zealand MPs was stolen amid Chinese state-sponsored cyber espionage targeting two arms of the country’s Parliament could test the long-standing trade relations between the two countries.

Featured

Funding boost for red meat

Two major red meat sector projects are getting up to a combined $1.7 million in funding from the New Zealand Meat Board (NZMB).

Otago's supreme winner

Angus Barr and Tara Dwyer of The Wandle, Lone Star Farms in Strath Taieri have been named the Regional Supreme Winners at the Otago Ballance Farm Environment Awards in Dunedin.

Editorial: Wake up Wellington

OPINION: The distress that the politicians and bureaucrats are causing to the people of Wairoa and the wider Tairāwhiti is unforgivable.

TV series to combat food waste

Rural banker Rabobank is partnering with Food Rescue Kitchen on a new TV series which airs this weekend that aims to shine a light on the real and growing issues of food waste, food poverty and social isolation in New Zealand.

National

Machinery & Products

PM opens new Power Farming facility

Morrinsville based Power Farming Group has launched a flagship New Zealand facility in partnership with global construction manufacturer JCB Construction.

AGTEK and ARGO part ways

After 12 years of representing the Landini and McCormick brands in New Zealand, Bay of Plenty-based AGTEK and the brands’…

100 years of Farmall Tractors

Returning after an enforced break, the Wheat and Wheels Rally will take place on the Lauriston -Barhill Road, North-East of…

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Cut with care

OPINION: The new government has clearly signalled big cuts across the public service.

Bubble burst!

OPINION: Your canine crusader is not surprised by the recent news that New Zealand plant-based ‘fake meat’ business is in…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter