Wednesday, 25 September 2019 10:55

Fencing setbacks unacceptable – Fonterra

Written by  Sudesh Kissun
Fonterra chair John Monaghan. Fonterra chair John Monaghan.

Fonterra is rejecting a Government proposal for five-metre fencing setbacks on all dairy farms.

Co-op chairman John Monaghan points out farmer shareholders pledged six years ago to fully fence defined waterways on every farm.

“Within 24 months, more than 90% of those waterways were fenced,” he said.

“It’s something we should all be proud of. Instead this proposal punishes us for being proactive with little added benefit and at huge cost.

“Pulling down fences and making farmers start again shouldn’t be a priority.”

In a note to farmer shareholders last week, Monaghan described the proposed five-metre fencing setbacks as “unacceptable”.

Also unacceptable to the co-op is the Government’s proposal to set ‘bottom lines’ for dissolved inorganic nitrogen (DIN).

Monaghan believes the bottom lines for nitrogen and phosphorus in rivers need to be tailored.
“The proposal must consider local contexts or ambitions, and should be backed up by analysis of the economic cost to individual farmers, our communities and wider regional economies,” he said.
“In the current proposal, farms in some parts of New Zealand would have to make nitrogen reductions in excess of 50%. We would expect robust analysis to justify this decision.”

Monaghan says Fonterra supports the Government’s overall goal to improve freshwater.
“Every dairy farmer understands the importance of freshwater to our businesses and our communities,” he says. “We all know NZ can have both healthy freshwater and a thriving agricultural economy.”

But he wants people to take the emotion out of the debate and make these critical decisions based on science, data and facts.

“There is a lot of emotion on all sides of this debate, and rightly so.  New Zealanders are passionate about the environment. But at the end of the day we all want the same thing: clean, thriving freshwater existing alongside a thriving farming economy.
“There are a number of proposals we support and we will work with you to help you meet these.”

In particular, Fonterra welcomes the Government’s acknowledgement of the value of farm environment plans (FEPs).

It wants the Government to go further and make them mandatory for all farmers and growers. About 23% of Fonterra farmers already have a FEP tailored to help them farm within environmental limits.

“Continuing to help farmers get FEPs to identify improvement areas will be far more effective in restoring freshwater quality,” Monaghan said.

Fonterra's commitment

• Farm within regional environmental limits

• Encourage strong environmental farming practices

• Reduce water use and improve wastewater quality at manufacturing plants

• Work together on waterway health

• Invest in science and innovation to find new solutions

• Make the products people value most.

» Connect with Rural News

More like this

Fonterra chairman feels the heat

Frustrated Fonterra farmers called for chairman John Monaghan to take responsibility for the co-op’s financial debacle and step down.

Two re-elected to co-op

Re-elected Fonterra directors Andy Macfarlane and Donna Smit are looking forward to another three years on the board.

» The RNG Weather Report


Food bowl or toilet bowl?

New Zealand shouldn't become a 'toilet bowl' of trees for other countries' carbon dioxide commitments, explains John Jackson.


What’s your favourite plant?

Forest owners are urging people to vote for tōtara as plant of the year in a poll being conducted by the New Zealand Plant Conservation Network.

» Connect with Rural News

» Connect with Rural News

» The RNG Weather Report

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Logging spin

OPINION: The Hound notes that the foreign-owned and controlled NZ forestry industry is starting to feel the pressure of the…

EU waste

OPINION: This old mutt was interested to read a recent New York Times expose of the European Union’s agriculture subsidy…

» Connect with Rural News