increase font size
“Play the long game,” economist Cameran Bagrie says.
Banks should act sensibly when dealing with debt-ridden farmers, says economist Cameron Bagrie.
He’s urging banks to “play the long game, as opposed to the short game”.
Farmers are paying off debt: Bagrie believes the sector must continue to deleverage. But he warns that farmers’ incomes are under pressure from “a highly uncertain world” and domestic challenges like drought: they loom large on global dairy prices.
“The income side of the ledger looks very good, well the banks would want a fair chunk of that cash but we also need to see sensible heads out of the banking sector in regards to how these things unfold,” he told Rural News.
“We are obviously in a highly uncertain world at the moment: we are also seeing financial pressure increase in the likes of Northland where the drought is starting to bite.
“I just hope the banking sector plays the long – as opposed to the short – game.”
He believes the dairy sector is going through a relatively orderly debt leveraging process: the dairy payout remains the critical part.
“Up around 7 bucks, that is keeping the process orderly….if that income side of the ledger gives way, watch out.”
Bagrie, a former chief economist at ANZ, spoke last week at DairyNZ Farmers Forum in Northland on understanding opportunities and managing risks in the sector.
Bagrie says dairy sector debt has fallen in 2019 to $41 billion: he wants farmers to slash debt by another $10 billion.
“My personal view is that debt needs to go down closer to $30b than $40b: I think we will get there.
“Things have gone a bit out of whack but the sector is going through a corrective phase.”
Bagrie, who now run his own consultancy, says the coronavirus outbreak isn’t helping the dairy sector and the global economy.
The last two Global Dairy Trade auctions have recorded big drops in dairy prices. Whole milk powder price is now below US$3000/metric tonne, from a high of US$3331/MT two months ago.
Bagrie believes the global economy is now incredibly vulnerable.
“Whether coronavirus is the trigger for some sort of credit-related event, we don’t know.”
Bagrie says China takes over 20% of all NZ exports but for some sectors like dairy, export numbers are higher. China takes a quarter of every drop of milk Fonterra exports.
Not all bad news
Cameron Bagrie says he has lot of concerns for the global economy in 2020 looking across all sectors.
However, New Zealand is better placed than other countries to ride out the storm.
“NZ is a small open trading nation: we are going to get impacted by interest rates, currency, commodity prices and demand for exports.
“It’s co-related to what goes around us, we are not immune.”
But there’s not all bad news.
The NZ dollar has fallen against the US dollar, the Reserve Bank still has “policy ammunition” and government books look in good shape.
“We are in a reasonable space to ride out what could be a volatile 2020,’ he says.
Dairy and beef farmers could be eligible for lower interest lending options for financing Halter on their farms, with ANZ, ASB and BNZ now offering a pathway to sustainability loans for New Zealand’s largest virtual fencing provider.
OPINION: Groundswell has given ANZ a shout-out for, so far, being the only one of the big four Aussie-owned banks not to set emissions reduction targets for its dairy sector loan book.
Major rural lenders are welcoming a call by farmers for the Commerce Commission to investigate their net-zero emissions target.
ANZ agricultural economist Susan Kilsby is describing the 2024-25 dairy season as ‘a cracker’.
ANZ says the latest cut to its floating rates will be welcome news to many of its business and agri customers still feeling the effects of high inflation and interest rates.
New Zealand’s 2025 kiwifruit harvest has started with the first fruit picked in the Bay of Plenty, marking the earliest ever harvest.
Northland Field Days organisers are giving a big shout out to exhibitors who have signed up for the three-day event later this month.
Management practices that aim to cull the poor performers rather than boost the best are a key to success for Canterbury deer farmer Stu Stokes.
Any farmer that harvests or buys crops risks inviting one of the world's most invasive pest plants onto their property - to their detriment.
Gisborne's record hot dry summer weather has produced rewards for one of the country's largest commercial growers based in the region - Leaderbrand.
Apricots from New Zealand’s largest Summer series exporter, Ardgour Valley Orchards, burst onto the world stage and domestic supermarket shelves under the Temptation Valley brand last month.
OPINION: Ruth Richardson, architect of the 1991 ‘Mother of all Budgets’ and the economic reforms dubbed ‘Ruthanasia’, added her two…
OPINION: Why do vegans and others opposed to eating meat try to convince others that a plant based diet is…
