Wednesday, 17 July 2013 15:25

Editorial - Common sense prevails

Written by 

HORIZONS REGIONAL Council deserves credit for its attempt to minimise the fallout on dairy farmers caused by the worrisome One Plan. 

 

A cynic would say that with local government elections looming the council had to try to clean up the mess caused by the plan – the work of councillors and others. Otherwise the political fallout could have been interesting, to say the least. 

The council’s temporary solution will allow all dairy farmers the right to farm for varying lengths of time depending on their proposals for mitigating nitrogen leaching on their farms.

 Here lies a problem: some of the N leaching targets set out in the Environment Court-approved plan are basically unachievable by some farmers. As Andrew Hoggard, of Federated Farmers, rightly asks, “why have rules if people can’t meet them – it’s plain silly”. Unless the objective is to put them out of business.

The council seems to be implementing its One Plan in a way that will give them time – who knows when – to go for a ‘plan change’. Essentially this means re-litigating some controversial aspects of the plan to try to get it right. For a few weeks the council had it right – then Fish and Game, DOC and the council itself attacked, or failed to support, the decisions made by the council’s own commissioners and the result is a plan from hell.

One Plan is a lawyers’ gravy train. Cost estimates vary, but by the time this is settled in, say, five years, it will have cost ratepayers and interested parties about $20 million. Then the implementation costs hit the council and farmers.  

The council keeps insisting it is blameless for the mess-up. That notion is delusional.  While bureaucrats and councillors bungle their way through, ratepayer farmers are being stung twice and the economy of the region placed in jeopardy. 

To be fair, the council after hefty persuasion by DairyNZ, has come up with a temporary sort-of livable implementation programme. It’s the least the council could have done given the angst it has caused to farmers and the rural community.

 A rumour surfaced that One Plan was to be entered in some award contest – presumably for the cock-up of the decade.  

Featured

LIC ends year with $30.6m profit

Herd improvement company LIC has ended the 2024-25 financial year in a strong position - debt-free and almost quadrupling its net profit.

Farmers back Government pause on RMA plan changes

There's been widespread support from the primary sector for the Government's move to put the brakes on local authorities to do any more work on planning changes ahead of major changes to the Resource Management Act (RMA).

Flood-hit Tasman farms begin long recovery

People affected by the recent two severe flood events in the Tasman district are weary and exhausted trying to deal with the devastation on their farms and orchards, according to the head of the Rural Support Trust (RST) in the region.

National

Machinery & Products

Fliegl offers effluent solutions

Founded in Germany as recently as 1977, today, the Fliegl Group employs more than 1100 workers, offering an expansive range…

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

It's all about economics

OPINION: According to media reports, the eye-watering price of butter has prompted Finance Minister Nicola Willis to ask for a…

» Connect with Dairy News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter