Wednesday, 04 October 2023 12:55

Earn loyalty, respect of farmers

Written by  Garry Reymer
Garry Reymer Garry Reymer

OPINION: I believe Fonterra’s governance and representation as well as capital structure are interconnected, and both are important to the survival of the co-op.

Apathy is one of the biggest killers of any organisation and a threat to Fonterra. In fact, it is also probably one of the reasons our councils (local government) perform so badly, but that’s another story.

Fonterra is never going to be able to buy loyalty just by discounting its share price. Loyalty and respect are earned.

If we go back first for a bit of history: it was common to have a dairy co-op in almost every small rural centre. When that was the case, the farmers all knew the board members personally. They saw them at the footy club, church, school or wherever. They all had active discussions and farmers felt involved and connected. As the mergers took place, this was held together by better transport to larger centres and more regional co-ops with ward directors, so someone with a close connection to your region.

Fonterra now has no wards, and 4 of the 11 directors are not even farmers (appointed by the board) and Fonterra want to reduce the size of its board. To make it worse, from a farmer representation point of view, only the definition of ‘farmer director’ is very loose, and if you are a trustee of a farming company you qualify as a farmer director. This can make that director no different from an appointed director. You may never have seen the back end of a cow in your life or have a good connection to the land.

The farmers are feeling more removed all the time. Fonterra has a Co-operative Council which is supposed to bring the representation role back to the land and connect on farm. This, in my opinion, is not working that well and many farmers question the value of the council and call it more of a lapdog than watchdog. I feel now it is just an old dog past its working life.

If we are serious about protecting Fonterra and serious about delivering best-practice governance and serious about farmer representation and engagement, I feel we need to rethink all aspects of our governance representation and capital structure. Rather than look at these things individually as we have been.

A key part of this is the reinvigorate the council. The Co-operative Council needs to be more like the shareholders association or a cornerstone investor. If we can achieve that it should drive farmer engagement.

Here’s how it would work: Many years ago, George Moss came up with a plan to utilise every vote in Fonterra, without taking away any shareholder rights.

Any vote not taken by the farmer shareholder themselves would default to the Co-operative Council.

The council would get this vote for any matter that shareholders get to vote on including the director election.

This would give the council some real power. The results would be many fold:

  1. It would empower the council.
  2. It would make farmers sit up and take notice of what the council was doing and saying.
  3. It would ensnare a better quality of person on the council table. This would happen because of the engagement between farmer and council, and farmers would want to be sure that someone with these newfound powers would have the skills to use it wisely.
  4. It would invigorate the engagement between farmers and Fonterra itself because a lot of farmers would not want to forfeit their vote, so will make sure they are abreast of matters concerning the business.
  5. It should help Fonterra be more agile in its decision making. Having a powerful cornerstone shareholder that it knows would have the farmers' back and best interest at heart.
  6. It should deliver better governance by allowing for a smaller board first but also director candidates would need to get the vote of the council to have any real chance of getting elected. The council should be better placed to access and candidate than individual farmers.

If Fonterra went down this road it could also de-list and once again be a pure co-op with a nominal share price. This is not a guarantee that Fonterra would be protected from a hostile takeover, but it would address the constant chatter about entry, exit strategies and what is fair value. All of which help divide opinion and the co-op.

Depending on how Fonterra used the new DIRA legislation, the share price value would transfer to the Fonterra supply number. The board needs to come out and tell farmers what a strong co-op is. Now their best answer is "large with the majority of NZ milk". I would argue it is a loyal engaged shareholder base who have pride in their company.

Garry Reymer is a Fonterra shareholder and Federated Farmers Waikato executive.

More like this

Chinese strategy

OPINION: Fonterra may have sold its dairy farms in China but the appetite for collaboration with the country remains strong.

LCAs tackle false narratives

The quest to measure, report and make sense of the energy that goes into food production has come a long way in the past 25 years.

$3b windfall?

Fonterra's proposed sale of its global consumer business could fetch over $3 billion but not all proceeds will end up in the pockets of farmer shareholders.

Featured

Better animal genetic gain system

A governance group has been formed, following extensive sector consultation, to implement the recommendations from the Industry Working Group's (IWG) final report and is said to be forming a 'road map' for improving New Zealand's animal genetic gain system.

SIDE 2025's new schedule, venue

Annual farmer gathering, the South Island Dairy Event (SIDE), is set to make history as it heads to Timaru for the first time.

Taranaki piggery goes solar

Installing 400 solar panels at their Taranaki piggery and cropping operation will have significant environmental, financial and animal welfare benefits for the Stanley family.

Editorial: Keep FTAs coming

OPINION: The dairy industry will  be a major beneficiary of a new free trade deal between NZ and the Gulf Co-operation Council (GCC).

National

Organic sector backtracks on GE

Organics Aotearoa New Zealand (OANZ) says the Government’s new gene editing and genetic modification reforms could leave New Zealand as…

$3b windfall?

Fonterra's proposed sale of its global consumer business could fetch over $3 billion but not all proceeds will end up…

Machinery & Products

Milk Sustainability Centre launched

The recently announced Milk Sustainability Centre – a collaboration between global giant John Deere and milking and feed specialists De…

Data connection made easier

New Holland and Case IH are introducing new advancements in their precision technology stack to make farming easier and more…

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

Chinese strategy

OPINION: Fonterra may have sold its dairy farms in China but the appetite for collaboration with the country remains strong.

Not fair

OPINION: The Listener's latest piece on winter grazing among Southland dairy farmers leaves much to be desired.

» Connect with Dairy News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter