Tuesday, 29 November 2022 13:55

What went wrong?

Written by  Peter Burke
Jim van der Poel Jim van der Poel

So what went wrong? That's the big question being asked by industry leaders.

"I don't know what happened, but in the end they (the Government) got it so fundamentally wrong," says DairyNZ chair, Jim van der Poel.

He made the comments as DairyNZ lodged its submission to the Government on their proposal to deal with agricultural emissions. As well as making their own submission, DairyNZ is a party to the wider submission being made by the various industry groups which make up the He Waka Eke Noa (HWEN) consortium.

Van der Poel rather kindly suggested that the officials and Ministers who reviewed the HWEN submission and came up with the counter proposal, didn't realise the implications of their changes.

He says when the Government announced their counter proposal, they claimed it was what farmers had wanted, with just a few tweaks. He says, on the face of it, this appeared to be the case, but when his and other groups delved into the detail, it was abundantly clear this was not the case and their response was fundamentally different to the industry proposal and clearly not fit for purpose.

"You never quite know what happens in government. It would seem that a lot of people got involved in the process who were not involved in the initial discussions with us," van der Poel told Dairy News.

"Remember our initial proposal that was put to government was a collaboration of thirteen organisations: ten industry-based, a representative of the Federation of Maori Authorities and two government departments, being Ministry for Priamry Industries (MPI) and the Ministry for Environment (MfE).

"They were active participants in the process when it went forward to government. In our view, the final proposal which everyone signed up to was finely balanced and it was fit for purpose," he says.

But van der Poel says the changes made turned what HWEN had provided into a fundamentally different proposal. He says he's got no idea of how, on what basis and who made the changes. He says, in subsequent discussions when the implications of the changes were relayed back to officials, no one refuted their arguments.

"If you look at some of the potential consequences that come out of their proposal, it has quite an impact on NZ's potential export earnings going forward and also on rural communities - that's pretty random. If they would accept our proposals, there was a really good chance of hitting the right environmental targets but not having the disastrous consequences.

"The government proposal puts the reaching of targets as the number one priority to accept some carnage in the rural community as long as the targets are met. Whereas we have taken a totally different approach, which would incentivise behavioural change with farmers and still hit the targets and not have the impact on rural communities," he says.

More like this

DairyNZ supports vocational education reforms

DairyNZ is supporting a proposed new learning model for apprenticeships and traineeships that would see training, education, and pastoral care delivered together to provide the best chance of success.

Editorial: GMO furore

OPINION: Submissions on the Government's contentious Gene Technology Bill have closed.

Feds vow to keep Govt honest

Buoyed by a survey showing farmer confidence rising to its highest level in over a decade, Federated Farmers says it's not taking its foot off the pedal.

Turning NZ into a pine plantation

Federated Farmers meat and wool chair, Toby Williams says what the Government has effectively signed up for is a decade more of planting pine trees on productive land because that’s the only way for our country to achieve such a steep reduction.

Featured

DairyNZ supports vocational education reforms

DairyNZ is supporting a proposed new learning model for apprenticeships and traineeships that would see training, education, and pastoral care delivered together to provide the best chance of success.

The Cook Islands squabble

The recent squabble between the Cook Islands and NZ over their deal with China has added a new element of tension in the relationship between China and NZ.

Wyeth to head Synlait

Former Westland Milk boss Richard Wyeth is taking over as chief executive of Canterbury milk processor Synlait from May 19.

National

Certainty welcomed

There's been very little reaction to the government science reform announcement, with many saying the devil will be in the…

Science 'deserves more funding'

A committee which carried out the review into New Zealand's science system says the underinvestment will continue to compromise the…

Machinery & Products

Landpower win global award

Christchurch-headquartered Landpower and its Claas Harvest Centre dealerships has taken out the Global After Sales Excellence award in Germany, during…

Innovation, new products galore

It has been a year of new products and innovation at Numedic, the Rotorua-based manufacturer and exporter of farm dairy…

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

MVM struggles

OPINION: Nearly four years after buying a 75% stake in Southland processor Mataura Valley Milk (MVM), A2 Milk is still…

No backing down

OPINION: Fonterra isn't backing down in its fight with Greenpeace over the labelling of its iconic Anchor Butter.

» Connect with Dairy News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter