Wednesday, 29 October 2014 12:04

Motion to curb co-op spending tabled

Written by 

FONTERRA’S EXPANSION strategy should go on hold when its farmer suppliers aren’t getting a good return, says a shareholder who has tabled a remit for the cooperative’s annual meeting November 12.

 

“They’ve just got to stop spending for a while and consolidate a bit,” Murray Beach, Marlborough, told Dairy News. “I feel they’re doing a lot of spending while we’re not getting a lot of money.”

Beach says his remit isn’t a knee-jerk reaction to this year’s low forecast. Rather, it reflects two poor years, followed by one good, and now a “really bad year.”

“We should be getting more money from Fonterra than the other milk companies are paying their suppliers but we’re not.”

Beach’s remit, resolution 7 in Fonterra’s notice of annual meeting document, says overseas investment and New Zealand development spending should be put on hold when the payout is below $7/kgMS.

“They’ve got to think about the farms which aren’t going to make it. There are going to be a lot of farms sold up at the end of this season.”

And it’s not just farmers: staff and local economies are already feeling the hit, he adds. “We’ve already had to put one worker off.”

With 130 cows producing about 40,000kgMS off his farm at Havelock, $5/kgMS means “there’s not a lot of income” to meet ever-rising costs.

Beach says he’s not totally against Fonterra’s development plans, particularly those in New Zealand, but believes the cooperative should reduce debt (see sidebar) before embarking on more expansion which is effectively at farmers’ expense.

Asked if Fonterra is ‘living beyond its means’, he says: “That’s what the bank manager would tell us!”

Fonterra released its notice of annual meeting, including Beach’s resolution, to NZX on October 17. It includes a letter from chairman John Wilson which refers to all resolutions but Beach’s.

In the explanatory notes to resolutions, a statement that the “board unanimously does not support [Beach’s] proposal and recommends that you vote against it” is highlighted in bold, the only bold text used in the document other than headings and remuneration figures.

Beach says the board’s recommendation “isn’t cricket”. “Voters should be able to make up their own minds.”

He also says postal voting on such a resolution before the issue is debated at the annual meeting “doesn’t seem very democratic.” “I’ve been asked by [Fonterra] management if I want to go to speak at the meeting out of courtesy but by then 80% will have already voted.”

The notice also includes a shareholders council recommendation to vote against Beach’s proposal, saying the council debated the resolution at its September meeting and unanimously voted not to support it.

More like this

Winston's crusade

OPINION: A short-term sugar hit. That's what NZ First leader Winston Peters is calling the proposed sale of Fonterra's consumer and associated businesses.

Featured

Carrfields invests in new Ashburton R&D hub

The Ashburton-based Carrfields Group continues to show commitment to future growth and in the agricultural sector with its latest investment, the recently acquired 'Spring Farm' adjacent to State Highway 1, Winslow, just south of Ashburton.

Elite sheep dogs to go head-to-head at Ashburton A&P Show

A major feature of the Ashburton A&P Show, to be held on October 31 and November 1, will be the annual trans-Tasman Sheep Dog Trial test match, with the best heading dogs from both sides of the Tasman going head-to-head in two teams of four.

National

Machinery & Products

New pick-up for Reiter R10 merger

Building on experience gained during 10 years of making mergers/ windrowers, Austrian company Reiter has announced the secondgeneration pick-up on…

Krone EasyCut B1250 fold

In 2024, German manufacturer Krone introduced the F400 Fold, a 4m wide disc front mower, featuring end modules that hinge…

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

Microplastics problem

OPINION: Microplastics are turning up just about everywhere in the global food supply, including in fish, cups of tea, and…

Job cuts

OPINION: At a time when dairy prices are at record highs, no one was expecting the world's second largest dairy…

» Connect with Dairy News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter