Wednesday, 24 June 2020 07:56

Free trade proposal a slap in the face

Written by  Peter Burke
Malcolm Bailey. Malcolm Bailey.

Dairy companies Association of NZ chairman, Malcolm Bailey has launched a scathing attack on the European Union’s proposed free trade agreement.

He says the present deal is better than the so-called new offer and the offer is a slap in the face to New Zealand dairy farmers. 

He says the reported EU offer, comprised of miniscule quota volumes and high in-quota tariffs, could never credibly form part of a free trade agreement between the economies.   

“This falls short of even paying lip-serve to free trade. It is unashamed protectionism from the world’s largest dairy exporter,” he told Dairy News.

“The starting cheese quota of 1500 tonnes is less than a rounding error, at just 0.02% of the EU’s nearly nine million tonne cheese market.  The butter offer of 600 tonnes is similarly low at just 0.03% of the domestic market, and each tonne will attract a tariff of Euro 586 per tonne, significantly constraining its usability,” he says.

A point of contention right from the start in the FTA negotiations has been the geographical indicators where NZ has been using names for its cheese, which the EU is in effect claiming as its intellectual property. 

Bailey points out that NZ has been using these names such as gruyere, feta and parmesan for over 100 years and now there is an argument. Bailey says NZ should not give way on this issue.

“Adding insult to injury, EU dairy producers enjoy among the highest levels of trade distorting subsidies in the world – a practice that significantly disadvantages New Zealand exporters on the world market. This trade agreement is an opportunity for the EU to take real global leadership and send a positive signal for food trade.  It’s time for action to match words,” he says.

Bailey says Covid-19 has seen many countries turn towards protectionism in a bid to save their economies. But he says history tells us that the best way for countries to recover from an economic crisis is to trade their way out, not put up the shutters.

More like this

Oh, Canada!

New Zealand scored a landmark victory over Canada, stopping it from protecting its dairy industry and effectively blocking our dairy exports to that country.

NZ wins trade dispute against Canada

New Zealand’s Minister for Trade and Export Growth Damien O’Connor says he welcomes the CPTPP Panel’s ruling in favour of New Zealand in its trade dispute against Canada.

We need to do more on trade with India

Agriculture and Trade Minister Damien O’Connor was in India recently as part of a trade delegation. He gave a speech to the Confederation of Indian Industry in New Delhi. Here’s part of what he said:

Trade strategy must evolve - research

New research suggests New Zealand needs to evolve its trade strategy in order to capture more value from existing markets, especially if the country seeks to increase exports and grow the economy amid rising protectionism and geopolitical tensions.


NZ protein must adapt - report

According to a new report from the New Zealand China Council, New Zealand dairy, meat and seafood exporters need to keep up with rapidly evolving agri-food sustainability policies in China to ensure future market success.

Allied holds back dividend

Listed livestock trader Allied Farmers is retaining earnings and not paying shareholders a dividend for the 2023 financial year.

Geographical diversification

Rockit Global says horticulture has the potential to transform the rural Canterbury landscape over the next 20 years.


A well-oiled machine

Marlborough Sounds dairy farmer Gareth Parkes is a busy man. Not only is he the owner of Parlan Holstein Friesian…

BVD cases on the rise

The Waikato region is currently experiencing a concerning surge in Bovine Viral Diarrhea (BVD) cases within dairy herds, with the…

Machinery & Products

Quicke way to manage silage

Swedish manufacturer Quicke has released the new range of Silocut implements for increased efficiency and safety when managing silage.

New disc mower, rakes unveiled

Slovenian manufacturer SIP has released details of a new 10.2m disc mower conditioner combi, alongside two new ranges of twin…


CNH Industrial has completed its purchase of the global satellite navigation technology leader Hemisphere GNSS (Hemisphere) for a total price…

Shorter chop version of loader

German manufacturer Strautmann is launching a shorter chop version of its Magnon 10 loader wagon that was launched in 2019.

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

Plant-based joke

OPINION: Some users of social media website X, formerly Twitter, are hard to understand.

» Connect with Dairy News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter