Tuesday, 08 December 2015 13:55

Fonterra guilty of breaching contracts

Written by 
Former suppliers of NZDL took Fonterra to court over milk supply contracts. Former suppliers of NZDL took Fonterra to court over milk supply contracts.

Fonterra says it is considering its options after losing a High Court case taken by former suppliers of a failed South Island processor.

Fonterra group director governance and legal Mark Cronin says the judgment refers to complex and difficult issues about special contracts with farmers outside the co-op.

"We are now reviewing the reasoning as well as the implications of the decision," he told Dairy News.

Fonterra bought the New Zealand Dairies Ltd Studholme plant from the receivers in 2012.

It offered the former suppliers to the plant 'growth contracts' on inferior terms in order to placate its existing farmer suppliers; the former suppliers took the co-op to court.

In a written decision, Justice Matthew Muir says Fonterra's reasons for doing so stemmed from a "perceived need to assuage internal politics within its supplier base and included also an element of 'messaging' for the benefit of other farmers who might in the future be persuaded to leave Fonterra and support an independent".

Cronin says Fonterra is disappointed with the ruling.

"We're disappointed in the outcome.

"Fonterra's acquisition of the former NZDL plant benefited Fonterra and the supplying farmers who'd been left out-of-pocket by NZ Dairies Ltd, enabling significant retro-payments owed to them to be paid and ensuring ongoing milk collection.

"We'll be considering all our options, including the option of appeal."

More like this

Fonterra R&D: Innovation needs more than just PhDs

Common sense and good human judgement are still a key requirement for the super highly qualified staff working at one of New Zealand's largest and most important research facilities - Fonterra's R&D Centre at Palmerston North.

Featured

LIC ends year with $30.6m profit

Herd improvement company LIC has ended the 2024-25 financial year in a strong position - debt-free and almost quadrupling its net profit.

Farmers back Government pause on RMA plan changes

There's been widespread support from the primary sector for the Government's move to put the brakes on local authorities to do any more work on planning changes ahead of major changes to the Resource Management Act (RMA).

Flood-hit Tasman farms begin long recovery

People affected by the recent two severe flood events in the Tasman district are weary and exhausted trying to deal with the devastation on their farms and orchards, according to the head of the Rural Support Trust (RST) in the region.

National

Machinery & Products

Fliegl offers effluent solutions

Founded in Germany as recently as 1977, today, the Fliegl Group employs more than 1100 workers, offering an expansive range…

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

It's all about economics

OPINION: According to media reports, the eye-watering price of butter has prompted Finance Minister Nicola Willis to ask for a…

» Connect with Dairy News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter