Tuesday, 05 September 2023 08:55

Capital structure 'not working'

Written by  Sudesh Kissun
Fonterra’s share price lost 27c, hovering around $2.47/share last week. Fonterra’s share price lost 27c, hovering around $2.47/share last week.

A Fonterra shareholder says the co-operative's capital structure experiment has gone wrong.

Garry Reymer, Cambridge, who unsuccessfully stood for Fonterra director elections in 2014, says the co-operative's milk price to suppliers are dropping.

And with poort cashflow on farms, the mood among shareholders isn't good, he adds.

"If we try and look forward 12 months it will be even worse, unless there is a big turnaround in milk price," Reymer told Dairy News.

Reymer points out that the forecast advance rate is $5.50/kgMS to the end of May, $1.20 down on last season.

With a forecast price mid-point of $6.75, the deferred payment will be $1.25 - down $0.25 on the last deferred payment.

Fonterra is expected to pay a good dividend given the milk price, an input cost, is low. Reymer anticipates a dividend of around 38c/share.

He also points out that there will be no more capital distribution like the 50c/share paid out to shareholders last month.

"Add that all up and the hypothetical 150,000 kgMS dairy farm is $180,000 down on season cashflow and $124,000 down on the end of year retro payments, for a total of $304,000.

"So, with poor cashflows, high overdraft/debt, low share price, and the clincher is poor shareholder engagement with the co-op, you have a situation where a hostile takeover offer could well be tabled."

He says the Asia Pacific region is forecast to have a milk deficit by 2030.

"This is on the back of 209 million more people and a small lift in consumption per capita. It is not hard to imagine then that some of these countries will look to secure their own milk pools if their domestic supply is not able to keep up with demand.

"Then if you throw into the mix the ageing farming population and the water reforms such as the national policy on fresh water, PC1 and some scope 3 coming, I can see many farmers who would be receptive to any reasonable offer.

"So, I think there's definitely a risk to Fonterra facing a takeover."

Fonterra's share price has lost 23c/share in the last two weeks alone. It was trading at $2.47/share last week.

Reymer says he's not surprised at Fonterra's share price falling after the $800m capital distribution to shareholders.

"This is not unusual behaviour for a share, and I suspect the same would happen post dividend," he says.

"I have heard of farmers selling before the distribution because, as they have picked correctly, the drop was greater than the distribution.

"If that happens again post dividend then we could be looking at a high $1 or very low $2 share price.

"What does this all mean, you may ask? I have commented in the past and even talked about it many years ago when I stood for director, that if Fonterra got things wrong on capital structure, they would be vulnerable to a takeover offer."

Reymer says a key point around takeovers is apathy.

Garry Reymer FBTW

Fonterra shareholder Garry Reymer says farmers are giving up on the co-op.

"If you look at the former big dairy co-ops across the Tasman, they died mainly because the board and management lost touch with its shareholders.

"This is exactly where we are at today with Fonterra.

"In the early days of Fonterra, we would fill the halls and rugby clubrooms around the country for accounts meetings or director road shows.

"Now you are lucky to get 30 or 40 people to a director meeting in Hamilton. Farmers are giving up on the co-op because they are sick of being told they are listened to, but not heard."

A Drop In The Ocean

Fonterra's attempt to stabilise its share price by launching a $50 million share buyback scheme won't work, says Garry Reymer.

He points out that farmers will only need to hold 1 share for 3 kgMS supplied to the co-op.

"This has the potential to free up hundreds of millions of shares and something that Fonterra will not be able to soak up with $50m," he says.

"And, once you have a surplus of anything, the price drops even further.

"What will be interesting in all this is how it plays out and how much value shareholders will put on the dividend.

"If investment advisers think dividend is going to support the share price then they would be advising clients to buy Fonterra units now.

"If the future earnings of Fonterra had the same confidence in the market of, say a2 Milk at its peak, the unit price might be up around $30 instead of $3."

More like this

Chinese strategy

OPINION: Fonterra may have sold its dairy farms in China but the appetite for collaboration with the country remains strong.

LCAs tackle false narratives

The quest to measure, report and make sense of the energy that goes into food production has come a long way in the past 25 years.

$3b windfall?

Fonterra's proposed sale of its global consumer business could fetch over $3 billion but not all proceeds will end up in the pockets of farmer shareholders.

Featured

Better animal genetic gain system

A governance group has been formed, following extensive sector consultation, to implement the recommendations from the Industry Working Group's (IWG) final report and is said to be forming a 'road map' for improving New Zealand's animal genetic gain system.

SIDE 2025's new schedule, venue

Annual farmer gathering, the South Island Dairy Event (SIDE), is set to make history as it heads to Timaru for the first time.

Taranaki piggery goes solar

Installing 400 solar panels at their Taranaki piggery and cropping operation will have significant environmental, financial and animal welfare benefits for the Stanley family.

Editorial: Keep FTAs coming

OPINION: The dairy industry will  be a major beneficiary of a new free trade deal between NZ and the Gulf Co-operation Council (GCC).

National

Organic sector backtracks on GE

Organics Aotearoa New Zealand (OANZ) says the Government’s new gene editing and genetic modification reforms could leave New Zealand as…

$3b windfall?

Fonterra's proposed sale of its global consumer business could fetch over $3 billion but not all proceeds will end up…

Machinery & Products

Milk Sustainability Centre launched

The recently announced Milk Sustainability Centre – a collaboration between global giant John Deere and milking and feed specialists De…

Data connection made easier

New Holland and Case IH are introducing new advancements in their precision technology stack to make farming easier and more…

» Latest Print Issues Online

Milking It

Chinese strategy

OPINION: Fonterra may have sold its dairy farms in China but the appetite for collaboration with the country remains strong.

Not fair

OPINION: The Listener's latest piece on winter grazing among Southland dairy farmers leaves much to be desired.

» Connect with Dairy News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter