Tip Top sale no sweet fix
Selling the iconic ice cream business Tip Top won’t end Fonterra’s financial woes, says broker Grant Williamson, of Hamilton Hindin Greene.
This follows last week’s GlobalDairyTrade auction in which the overall index rose 16.5% and whole milk powder rose 20% to US$2495/t.
ASB has raised its forecast milk price by 50c from $4.50/kgMS to $5/kgMS and BNZ by $1.20, from $3.80 to $5/kgMS. All eyes will be on Fonterra this week to see if it revises its forecast milk price of $3.85/kgMS at the release of its annual results on Thursday.
Doug Steel, BNZ economist, says just six weeks ago there was probably a downside risk to the co-op’s previous forecast of $3.80/kgMS.
This risk squared to neutral, then at the last auction it went to upside and it has now lifted, showing how much things have changed in the past couple of months.
Steel says they had been hoping for a decent increase in last week’s GDT -- maybe in the 5-10% range. But at 16.5% the rise was “encouraging”. Prices are moving in the right direction and obviously less volume is part of it.
“Potentially there is a change in buyer psychology. When prices were falling rapidly before, there was the tendency [for them] to step back, thinking [they] would get the product cheaper at the next event,” he says.
“Now that prices have clearly turned higher, there seems to be more keenness to buy now and there is an increase in the number of unsatisfied buyers which suggests there are more of them and they are struggling to get product, which is pushing prices higher in the near term.
“We are of the opinion there [will be] some further gains over the course of this current season but certainly we haven’t factored in anything like the pace of climbs we have seen in the last three events.”
BNZ is factoring in prices getting to $2700/t to $2800/t for whole milk powder. “They are currently averaging about $2500/t, so we are forecasting a little bit higher but nowhere near the degree of increase we have seen over the last few events.
“We have stressed over the last few months the wide range of possibilities and there are many moving parts out there -- whether it be demand from China, or wobbles in financial markets or indeed just [the state of] the weather. We know there is a very strong El Nino but we don’t know what will be its impact on production.
“When there are so many things in play the market tries to figure out all those things and you see volatility in prices and that’s what we have.”
ASB rural economist Nathan Penny says the bank expected a decent increase at last week’s auction of about 15% for whole milk powder so the 20% was within the range of its forecasts.
“The market is still a bit focused on what Fonterra is doing with its auction volumes. That may explain some of that additional price strength for now,” he says. But he says the market has not yet fully realised the potential extent of a drop in NZ milk production which the ASB forecasts could be up to 5%.
Rabobank economist Emma Higgins says the massive jump in GDT prices is extremely pleasing and positive news. “The underlying reasons are largely a decrease in available supply and an increase in interest. The main driver is falling supply which is creating a short term mini-market,” she says. Rabobank predicts NZ production could fall up to 8%.
“We have more buyers in the latest auction and these have been largely spooked by the prospect of further volume reductions, and some are looking to sell their 2016 pipelines at the lowest-possible prices and they are tied to NZ product in some cases.”
However she says the GDT is unlikely to continue rallying at these extreme rates until there is a major shift in the fundamentals and a rebalancing of supply and demand factors.
“That is starting. Farmgate prices are falling elsewhere; we have seen farmers converge on Brussels protesting at the milk price. Once prices start falling that is a huge signal to decrease production and that’s what we need when the world is still awash with milk,” she says.
