Tuesday, 24 August 2021 06:55

Over regulated

Written by  Peter Burke
Former High Commissioner Sir Lockwood Smith. Former High Commissioner Sir Lockwood Smith.

New Zealand is adopting a top-heavy regulatory approach similar to the European Union, according to former High Commissioner and Trade Minister Sir Lockwood Smith.

He told Rural News that EU regulations are top-down heavy, expensive and don't work. He says the present government is following a similar philosophy to the EU with its regulatory approach.

"That is one of the reasons why the UK left the EU. They wanted to get into world's best practice for regulations and NZ, Australia and America were seen to be leading the way in this, with the focus on outcomes and a light-handed approach that produces good outcomes that are basically risk-managed."

Smith says at the recent Red Meat Sector Conference there were claims that farmers did not understand the environmental issues and there was criticism of the Groundswell protests.

He says the reality is that most farmers want to improve the quality of freshwater, improve biodiversity and make progress on carbon emissions.

"The problem is the way the Government is going about it. Theirs is an intractable, unworkable, heavy-handed, top-down way," he says.

"The freshwater regulations are a disaster because NZ catchments and soil types and its environment changes so much across the country and one set of regulations will never work. They are just killing off some of the excellent fresh water work going on around our regions."

Smith also rejected claims by a speaker at the conference who claimed that NZ agriculture was not innovating enough. He says the agriculture sector has made huge gains over the years through quality, science-based research and is continuing to do this.

"The only period when NZ agriculture didn't innovate was the period from 1973 through to 1984 when we had the big subsidies. Subsidies kill innovation but agriculture has been hugely innovative since then," he says.

Finally, Smith - who before entering Parliament spent 13 years in universities, including lecturing at Massey University and as Commonwealth Scholar at the Waite Research Institute in Adelaide - says he's concerned that NZ's universities are becoming a little "side tracked".

He says NZ needs to be doing work on things like regenerative agriculture, but making sure that if we go down that track, it is backed by sound science.

"If it is just a marketing thing, one day the bubble will burst," Smith told Rural News. "If you have not based your productive system on sound science it will collapse and NZ cannot afford that."

He says we have to ensure, as we have up until now, that sound science underpins our productive systems.

More like this

O'Connor's overseas odyssey

Agriculture Minister Damien O'Connor continued his overseas odyssey in the past week with multiple meetings in the US, Europe and Ireland - all aimed at sorting out trade issues which in the case of Europe dairy is a major issue.

Mr O'Connor goes to Washington!

As Rural News revealed several weeks ago, Trade and Export Growth Minister Damien O'Connor is on his way to Europe and the United States to meet with key partners, including representing New Zealand at the G20 Trade Ministers' meeting in Italy.

Mission impossible

Agriculture and Trade Minister Damien O'Connor is off to Europe soon to try and breathe some life into free trade talks between NZ and the UK, and NZ and the European Union.

UK/EU trade scrap worries exporters

Britain's decision to break its deal with the EU over Brexit is creating uncertainty for NZ dairy exporters, according to Malcolm Bailey — chair of the Dairy Companies Association of NZ (DCANZ).

Clock ticking on EU meat deal

Trade experts are warning that time is running out to secure the future of New Zealand red meat exports to the European Union.


Industry reacts to UK FTA

Primary industries stakeholders  are welcoming the new Free Trade Agreement (FTA) with the United Kingdom announced today.

Historic FTA deal struck

Comprehensive, inclusive and high quality and providing fantastic opportunities for our exporters.

Tatua smashes $10 barrier

Waikato milk processor Tatua says keeping products moving to overseas customers during the pandemic was one of the highlights of…

Machinery & Products

Robo planter on the way

German farm machinery manufacturer Horsch says it is at an advanced stage of developing its aptly named Robo autonomous planter.

Keeping everyone safe

As tractors get larger and front linkage kits become more common, many have started fitting underrun or collision protection systems.

» The RNG Weather Report

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Flag it!

OPINION: Agriculture and Trade Minister Damien O'Connor tried to keep his latest overseas jaunt secret squirrel.

Oh dear!

OPINION: This old mutt suggests that farmers' growing discontent with Beef+Lamb NZ's performance is going to reach fever peak after…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter