Tuesday, 27 August 2019 11:55

Not the time for tax – Key

Written by  Sudesh Kissun
Former PM John Key and Graeme Clegg at the $50m factory opening. Former PM John Key and Graeme Clegg at the $50m factory opening.

Former Prime Minister John Key says imposing another tax on farmers now for greenhouse gas emissions won’t achieve much.

He says science will provide answers to methane and nitrate emissions over time. Until then a tax should be out of the question.

Speaking to Rural News last week at the opening of a $50 million upgrade to New Image Group (NIG) Nutritionals’ goat milk plant in South Auckland, Key said New Zealand farmers are good at adapting new technology.

“While large amount of greenhouse gas emissions in the agriculture sector come from methane and nitrate emissions, the reality is that at the moment we don’t have answers to that,” he said.

“Science will provide answers over time but if we expect our farmers to just pay another tax for no particular reason, what’s that really achieving?

“I think our farmers have historically shown that they are very good at adapting and taking up good technology -- paying their way when they can.”

Key says he’s not sure what a tax on emissions will achieve right now.

The Labour-led Government’s Interim Climate Change Commission (ICCC) recommended that agriculture be brought into the Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) from 2025 at a 95% discount rate, meaning farmers would pay only 5% of the cost of their emissions.

But National’s policy on this issue was that farmers should only be brought into the scheme if the agricultural sector “met certain conditions”, ie increased productivity levels and finding the science to make continuous improvements.

Key says while NZers care a lot for the environment, they also care about making sure people have jobs and the country remains an efficient food producer.

“The challenge is to marry the two together,” Key said.

And he is also worried about other challenges facing the farming sector: global trade wars, increasing on farm costs and volatile commodity prices.

“While we’ve had high commodity prices overall, things can change very quickly, as we’ve seen with log prices recently,” he said.

 Key says agriculture remains the backbone of NZ and the country needs our farmers to succeed.

On Fonterra, Key said it was disappointing that the co-op wouldn’t be paying a dividend this year. He hopes Fonterra will come right with the new chief executive Miles Hurrell at the helm.

“Ultimately, Fonterra needs to be strong because they are our global champion.”

Key said he is no longer invested in Fonterra units.

More like this

Paris Agreement - stay or leave?

There has been a bit of discussion in the media lately about the Paris climate agreement and whether New Zealand should withdraw from it.

Farmers want certainty

OPINION: We've been having constructive conversations with the Government recently around climate change and emissions from food production, but now is the time to see these conversations turn into action.

Methane targets disappoint farmers

Beef + Lamb New Zealand (B+LNZ) has reiterated calls for New Zealand to revise its methane targets after the Government's "disappointing" announcement of its revised Nationally Determined Contribution (NDC).

'Prepare for more pine trees'

Prepare for more pine trees. That's the message from North Otago farmer Jane Smith following the new methane emission targets recently announced by the Government.

Featured

Gongs for best field days site

Among the regular exhibitors at last month’s South Island Agricultural Field Days, the one that arguably takes the most intensive preparation every time is the PGG Wrightson Seeds site.

Feed help supplements Canterbury farmers meet protein goals

Two high producing Canterbury dairy farmers are moving to blended stockfeed supplements fed in-shed for a number of reasons, not the least of which is to boost protein levels, which they can’t achieve through pasture under the region’s nitrogen limit of 190kg/ha.

National

Machinery & Products

Buhler name to go

Shareholders at a special meeting have approved a proposed deal that will see Buhler Industries, the publicly traded Versatile and…

Grabbing bales made quick and easy

Front end loader and implement specialist Quicke has introduced the new Unigrip L+ and XL+ next-generation bale grabs, designed for…

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Risky business

OPINION: In the same way that even a stopped clock is right twice a day, economists sometimes get it right.

Should've waited

OPINION: The proposed RMA reforms took a while to drop but were well signaled after the election.

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter