Wednesday, 18 November 2020 07:55

Not all GHGs are the same

Written by  Staff Reporter
NZRSB chair Grant Bunting believes methane emissions should be accounted for differently from carbon dioxide and nitrous oxide. NZRSB chair Grant Bunting believes methane emissions should be accounted for differently from carbon dioxide and nitrous oxide.

The New Zealand Roundtable for Sustainable Beef (NZRSB) is calling for a new, more accurate, method for calculating methane emissions.

The new approach – called Global Warming Potential Star (GWP*) – has been developed based on the traditional emissions calculation method GWP100. The GPW100 method assumes all greenhouse gasses are cumulative (i.e. they never reduce). However, while this is correct for both carbon dioxide and nitrous oxide, methane has a lifespan of approximately 10 years before it disintegrates.

The NZRSB – described as a multi-stakeholder forum focused on producing sustainable beef in New Zealand – says this proves that different greenhouse gases behave differently.

“Modifying the use of GWP so that it accounts for the differences between short-lived and long-lived gases better connects emissions and warming. For countries with high methane emissions, this can make a big difference in how reducing emissions is understood and progressed,” says NZRSB chair Grant Bunting.

He acknowledges that methane has a climate impact and says the NZRSB is not advocating for this impact to be treated softer than other greenhouse gases. “However, given that methane survives in the atmosphere for 10 years – whereas the other two main greenhouse gases survive for thousands of years – we think methane emissions should be accounted for differently from carbon dioxide and nitrous oxide.”

Bunting says for the beef industry GWP* means that if herd numbers remain the same after 10 years then methane levels remain constant, with the quantity emitted equalling the quantity disintegrating.

“Importantly, if methane emissions are held constant, climate impact will remain constant,” he adds.

“The New Zealand red meat sector has already reduced methane emissions by more than 30% since 1990, so we’re already making good progress.”

Bunting explains that if all GHG emissions are treated the same – as they are using GWP100 – short-lived emissions are unequally accounted for.

“As we learn more, and the science develops, we need to ensure our approach remains relevant.”

Bunting believes the GWP* approach is gaining traction around the world.

“If New Zealand wants to be a world leader in this space it is time we started using an accurate measure that correlates to actual warming,” he adds.

More like this

NZ beef on show in Beijing

New Zealand's grass-fed beef drew large crowds at 13 of Beijing’s ultra-high-end retail stores – 7 Fresh.

Back the sector that backs NZ

OPINION: The biggest issue currently facing our industry is environmental policy, writes Beef+Lamb NZ chief executive Sam McIvor.


New investment in spirulina production

The Ministry for Primary Industries (MPI) Sustainable Food & Fibres Futures Fund will invest in a project to assess the viability of larger scale production of spirulina in New Zealand.


Lely offerings for the future

Dutch robotic specialist Lely launched a new farm management application called Horizon at its recent Future Farm Days 2020.


Dispelling wool's myths

Paul Alston believes that when comparing wool and synthetic carpets, wool wins every time.

Machinery & Products

Weeds in for a shock

WIith an increasing focus on reducing chemical herbicides, largely because of crop resistance and a potential build-up of residues, new…

V8 - a baler with a grunt

Following three years of testing with clients worldwide, Ireland-based manufacturer McHale has added a bigger model to its range of…

Virtual CV valuable tool

With a 12-year history of recruiting specialised operators from overseas to service the agricultural contracting industry, Hanzon Jobs typically brings…

» The RNG Weather Report

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Tough gig!

OPINION: This old mutt has a fair amount of sympathy for Ag Minister Damien O’Connor with the two associate ministers…

Cow killer

OPINION: The Hound was not surprised to hear well-known end-of-the-world doom-merchant ‘Dr’ Mike Joy is still as joyless as ever…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter