Tuesday, 30 June 2015 02:13

Impasse leaves $4m deficit in marketing budget

Written by 
Bill Falconer Bill Falconer

Meat Industry Association chairman Bill Falconer expects more discussions with Beef + Lamb NZ about promotion further down the track.

He agrees that if BLNZ decides in the long term not to continue with its country-of-origin marketing there will be a ‘gap’ in NZ’s overseas promotion. But how that gap is filled would have to be discussed by the industry at large.

Meat processors and exporters decided not to contribute 50% of the $8m cost of country-of-origin marketing now sponsored by BLNZ. Traditionally, BLNZ and its producer board predecessors have undertaken the generic marketing of beef and lamb, which latterly has been funded by the BLNZ commodity levy paid by farmers. 

Falconer says processors already spend at least $8 million on their own brand promotions and this will increase as new markets are developed. 

“Considerable time was spent usefully exploring the possible content and cost of a country-of-origin programme. 

“However, a solution could not be identified that would justify processors assuming 50% of the cost over and above the marketing investments they are committed to making and growing,” he says.

“Processors’ investment will continue to be directed to the product and consumer branded activities they develop with their distributors and retailer partners in existing and developing markets.”

John Mc Carthy, who said he could not talk as the Meat Industry Excellence chairman as they had not discussed the issue, but as a former Meat Board director, says the industry has had a lucky escape.

“Generic promotion does not work. Every study of generic promotion proves it is the least effective form of promotional activity there is. It is too bland and in this instance it would be too non-specific to make a difference.

“It is actually illustrates the destructive competitive model that is ruining this industry beyond the farmgate; why BLNZ is supporting this is beyond me.

“It belies common sense to imagine that where you’ve got a market model in which at least 50 different export licence holders, all competing against each other with basically the same product, all NZers competing against each other in a global market place – that any form of marketing using country-of-origin is going to make a blind bit of difference, let alone any profit to be attributed back to farmers.”

He says we currently don’t have a NZ provenance story; we have a number of players all trying to sell their stuff on the basis of individual company differentiation. “We’ve got the best provenance story in the world and we are wasting it through a destructively competitive model.

“This is what is driving the meat industry into oblivion.”

More like this

Red meat rebound

The red meat sector is poised for a strong rebound this season, with export receipts forecast to top $10 billion and farm profitability to almost double.

The future of beef breeding

Progeny testing at Pāmu’s Kepler farm in Southland as part of Beef + Lamb New Zealand’s Informing New Zealand Beef programme is showing that the benefits of hybrid vigour could have a massive impact on the future of beef breeding.

Methane targets disappoint farmers

Beef + Lamb New Zealand (B+LNZ) has reiterated calls for New Zealand to revise its methane targets after the Government's "disappointing" announcement of its revised Nationally Determined Contribution (NDC).

Featured

Being a rural vet is ‘fantastic’

Everyone from experienced veterinarians and young professionals to the Wormwise programme and outstanding clinics have been recognised in this year’s New Zealand Veterinary Association Te Pae Kīrehe (NZVA) awards.

National

Helping protect sheep from parasites

Everyone from experienced veterinarians and young professionals to the Wormwise programme and outstanding clinics have been recognised in this year’s…

Machinery & Products

Farmer-led group buys Novag

While the name and technology remain unchanged and new machines will continue to carry the Novag name, all the assets,…

Buhler name to go

Shareholders at a special meeting have approved a proposed deal that will see Buhler Industries, the publicly traded Versatile and…

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Make it 1000%!

OPINION: The appendage swinging contest between the US and China continues, with China hitting back with a new rate of…

Own goal

OPINION: The irony of President Trump’s tariff obsession is that the worst damage may be done to his own people.

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter