No reason to demonise farming
OPINION: New Zealand has said it is going to reduce its greenhouse gas emissions by ‘a lot’ and ‘in a short time’. One of those gases is methane. Our biggest producer of methane is livestock farming.
A recently formed pressure group is upping its campaign against any implementation of a methane tax.
The Methane Science Accord is backed by a number of prominent farmers and others. The group's backers includes the likes of Jane Smith, Hamish Carswell, Derek Daniell, Helen Mandeno, Hamish de Lautour, Deborah Alexander, John Sexton, Hamish Bielski, Neil Henderson and Owen Jennings. The group says it has been joined by hundreds of other farmers and is 'independent of but supported by' organisations such as Groundswell, FARM, 50 Shades of Green and the Rural Advocacy Group. It is asking more farmers to join the cause.
The accord says it is cranking up a campaign to help convince both rural and urban New Zealanders that taxing methane is 'unscientific, unjustified and economic insanity'.
"The most recent science is clear. Ruminant methane - our sheep and cattle burps - should not be taxed," it says. "It is too insignificant and trivial to be properly measured."
The group adds that the outgoing government and other political parties have been threatening action based on false science. They want to update them and save rural communities.
"Government and agricultural industry modelling showed that 20% of sheep and beef production will be lost - along with 5% of dairy output. That hurts farmers, their families, their communities. Our country cannot afford that cost."
The group says a tax on methane could cost the average farmer over $100,000 depending on the carbon price. "Why pay when they cannot tell you how much warming your farm is producing?"
It describes moves to implement a methane tax a "political sop" and that is not scientifically justified.
"The most recent, unrefuted science is clear - methane's ability to warm is too inconsequential to measure or be taxed."
The accord says claims that international customers will take action if we don't pay for our methane emissions should be left up to individual exporters to deal with.
"If their customers demand produce with certain condition, the exporter/processor needs to incentivise their suppliers," it says.
"Why should one company force a tax on all farmers to satisfy their consumers?"
The group also disputes claims that money paid in methane taxes will be returned to the industry.
"More than $700 million has been allocated already and is being spent on dubious pursuits. Why create an unnecessary money-go-round?"
It also takes aim at levy bodies who have supported moves to tax methane emissions, describing these organisations as out of step with farmers.
"They will have to answer to levy payers. HWEN went down a rabbit hole focused on targets instead of warming ability."
More: www.methane-accord.co.nz
Holstein Friesian excellence was front and centre at the 2025 Holstein Friesian NZ (HFNZ) Awards, held recently in Invercargill.
The work Fonterra has done with Ballance Agri-Nutrients Ltd, LIC and Ravensdown to save farmers time through better data connections has been recognised with a national award.
This past week has seen another round of negotiations between India and New Zealand to produce a free trade agreement (FTA) between the two countries.
Cautiously optimistic is how DairyNZ's regional manager for the lower North Island, Mark Laurence describes the mood of farmers in his patch.
The Infrastructure Commission has endorsed a plan by Chorus to expand fibre broadband to 95% of New Zealand much to the delight of rural women.
Questions are being raised about just how good the state of the dairy industry is - especially given that the average farmgate payout for the coming season is set to exceed $10/kgMS.
OPINION: Dust ups between rural media and PR types aren't unheard of but also aren't common, given part of the…
OPINION: The Hound hears from his canine pals in Southland that an individual's derogatory remarks on social media have left…