Tuesday, 13 September 2022 09:55

Climate canoe hits choppy waters

Written by  David Anderson
A group of farmers have written an open letter to Beef + Lamb NZ directors, demanding changes to the HWEN recommendations. A group of farmers have written an open letter to Beef + Lamb NZ directors, demanding changes to the HWEN recommendations.

A group of sheep and beef farmers have penned an open letter to Beef+Lamb NZ directors demanding they make changes to the current He Waka Eke Noa (HWEN) recommendations for mitigating agricultural emissions or face a vote of no confidence.

They have also called on all farmers to question their levy bodies, reconsider their membership of Federated Farmers and question their own meat processors and banks over their support for the current HWEN proposal, which they claim endorses a pricing mechanism based on "politics rather than science".

The letter states, "It's an affront that the Meat Industry Association, red meat processors, Federated Farmers and Beef+Lamb NZ have supported the proposal delivered to the Government, when BLNZ's own modelling states that this would see a significant number of farms exiting red meat production."

The group says it has abandoned any hope that HWEN in its current format will deliver any benefit to the country. It says it will cause widespread afforestation, community devastation and further intensification of land remaining in pastoral use. It accuses BLNZ of faltering in its decision making on agricultural emissions and departing from the aim of enabling sustainable food and fibre production for future generations.

"Instead, the current proposals (HWEN) are expected to drive one-in-four low-environmental impact sheep, beef and deer farmers out of business and strangle the remainder," the letter states. "While our industry 'leaders' and the Government bask in political glory, it will be 6,500 sheep, beef and deer farmers - and their communities, school and rural businesses - who will pay the price."

The concerned farmers accuse BLNZ - with the support of DairyNZ and Fonterra - of the destruction of sheep and beef farming to protect the higher emitting dairy sector.

"This is not an effective, fair or equitable way to achieve the Government's emissions reductions targets and works against the goals of the National Policy Statements for both freshwater and biodiversity."

The letter ends with a call to action from those "purporting" to represent the country's sheep, beef and deer farmers. "We request that you reject the untenable emissions pricing options proposed and support sheep, beef and deer farmers to form a sustainable emissions scheme based on warming, equity, environmental sustainability and on-farm viability."

If this does not happen, the farmers say they will call a special meeting of Beef+Lamb NZ and propose a vote of no confidence in all its directors.

 

More like this

FE survey underway

Beef + Lamb NZ wants farmers to complete a survey that will shed light on the financial toll of facial eczema (FE) at the farm level.

Ag aviation in strife

The downturn in the farming sector - especially sheep and beef - is having a detrimental impact on the agricultural aviation sector.

NZ out of step - report

New Zealand is out of step globally in looking to put a price on agricultural emissions from food production.

B+LNZ refutes UK animal welfare criticism

Beef + Lamb New Zealand (B+LNZ) says recent criticism from the UK’s Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs regarding New Zealand’s animal welfare standards are unfounded.

Featured

Fruit fly discovery 'concerning'

Horticulture New Zealand (HortNZ) says that discovery of a male Oriental fruit fly on Auckland’s North Shore is a cause for concern for growers.

Fonterra updates earnings

Fonterra says its earnings for the 2025 financial year are anticipated to be in the upper half of its previously forecast earnings range of 40-60 cents per share.

Nedap NZ launch

Livestock management tech company Nedap has launched Nedap New Zealand.

National

FE survey underway

Beef + Lamb NZ wants farmers to complete a survey that will shed light on the financial toll of facial…

Top dairy CEO quits

Arguably one of the country's top dairy company's chief executives, Richard Wyeth has abruptly quit Chinese owned Westland Milk Products…

Machinery & Products

New home for JCB Agriculture

Power Farming has announced a new chapter in its partnership with JCB, which having represented the UK-based company’s construction equipment…

CAT's 100th anniversary

While instantly recognised as the major player in construction equipment, Caterpillar Inc, more commonly known as CAT, has its roots…

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Ruth reckons

OPINION: Ruth Richardson, architect of the 1991 ‘Mother of all Budgets’ and the economic reforms dubbed ‘Ruthanasia’, added her two…

Veg, no meat?

OPINION: Why do vegans and others opposed to eating meat try to convince others that a plant based diet is…

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter