Tuesday, 20 December 2022 07:55

Carbon credit conundrum

Written by  David Anderson
Steve Cranston Steve Cranston

Claims by the Government that farmers will now get 'full credit' for all scientifically robust on farm carbon sequestration are wrong.

That's the belief of Waikato-based farm consultant Steve Cranston - a long-time critic of the He Waka Eke Noa (HWEN) proposal and plans to tax on-farm emissions. Cranston says - despite a recent government announcement that recognition of on-farm sequestration will be a core component of its work to reduce New Zealand's agricultural climate emissions - it will still exclude the vast majority of on-farm sequestration.

"This is due to a poorly understood and almost never mentioned additionality clause," he told Rural News. "I would estimate this clause to affect around 80% of the total sequestration currently happening on farms."

Cranston says the 'additionality clause' refers to active management over and above base-level sequestration.

"To put it into practice, if your farm has a stand of pre-1990 regenerating native forest sequestering 6.5 ton CO2 per/ha, HWEN will ask you to ensure it is fenced and employ pest control. They will then award an additional 0.5 ton CO2 per/ha for this 'active management'," he explains.

“However, what the HWEN partners have not explained to farmers is that 0.5 ton is all that farmers will receive, they will not get acknowledged for the full 7.0 tons per hectare that this stand of trees is now sequestering.”

Cranston claims that the Beef+Lamb NZ’s ‘know your numbers’ emissions calculator has only served to further entrench this deception.

“There is no mention of the additionality clause anywhere in that calculation,” he adds. “Farmers have been putting areas of trees into the calculator and thinking that they will receive credit for the full amount.”

Cranston reckons that there will be some “very upset farmers” when HWEN eventually gives them the actual numbers after factoring in the additionality clause.

“This clause is not based on science or IPCC guidelines; it is a political decision by this government to limit the amount of sequestration available to farmers to offset their emissions tax,” he adds.

Cranston says regenerating native forest meets the IPCC definition of ‘additionality’ because, at some point in time, farming practices changed that allowed this forest to regenerate.

“Farmers have every right to expect full credit for regenerating native forest, something they will currently only get pennies on the dollar for,” he claims.

Cranston believes that industry groups are being negligent in not telling farmers what exactly the additional clause actually means.

“Beef+Lamb and DairyNZ are obligated to front up and explain to farmers how much legitimate sequestration will still be excluded under the HWEN proposal.”

More like this

DairyNZ chair wants cross-party deal

New DairyNZ chair Tracy Brown says bipartisan agreement among political parties on emissions pricing and freshwater regulations would greatly help farmers.

Positive signs, says McClay

First up to the podium at the recent Tractor and Machinery Association (TAMA) Conference in Wellington, Minster for Agriculture, Todd McClay, reflected on a difficult 12 months, but hinted at signs that things were turning the corner, saying “when ag does well, New Zealand does well”.

Replacing farms with forests?

A horror story - that’s how Federated Farmers describes new research looking at forestry conversions’ impact on water quality.

Overreach

OPINION: When Groundswell showed up in the 'advocacy hub' at Fieldays alongside the same groups that brought you He Waka Eke Noa, the Hound feared the ginger group had been brought into the woke fold and given the old rubber ring.

One levy

OPINION: Industry-good bodies have had a torrid time recently, with some facing backlash from farmers particularly over their stance on emissions pricing and He Waka Eke Noa.

Featured

Farmers urged not to be complacent about TB

New Zealand's TBfree programme has made great progress in reducing the impact of the disease on livestock herds, but there’s still a long way to go, according to Beef+Lamb NZ.

Editorial: Making wool great again

OPINION: Otago farmer and NZ First MP Mark Patterson is humble about the role that he’s played in mandating government agencies to use wool wherever possible in new and refurbished buildings.

National

Machinery & Products

Farmer-led group buys Novag

While the name and technology remain unchanged and new machines will continue to carry the Novag name, all the assets,…

Buhler name to go

Shareholders at a special meeting have approved a proposed deal that will see Buhler Industries, the publicly traded Versatile and…

» Latest Print Issues Online

The Hound

Make it 1000%!

OPINION: The appendage swinging contest between the US and China continues, with China hitting back with a new rate of…

Own goal

OPINION: The irony of President Trump’s tariff obsession is that the worst damage may be done to his own people.

» Connect with Rural News

» eNewsletter

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter